Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Erdogan and Turkey’s battle for stability

Update : 21 Jul 2013, 06:04 AM

There is a recent movie dialogue that goes: “You die a hero or you live long enough to see yourself become the villain.” It’s an apt description of Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, the prime minister of Turkey. From his meteoric rise in the mid-90s as mayor of Istanbul to his Gezi Park mess today, it’s all his doing. Erdoğan getting elected as prime minister after AKP’s victory in 2002 just one year since its inception is testament to the political genius of this most underestimated leader who is misread as the benefactor of an era favourable to the Turkey he envisioned.

His governance started of well with several reform based initiatives that gained public support.  He soon positioned himself as a patriarchal figure in modern Turkish politics and fashioned himself as a founding leader of a “new republic” who was down-to-earth and listened to his voters. The rise of Erdoğan coincided with the people’s need for more democracy and that was something his party offered when they began their journey.

His story is all the more astonishing in a Turkey where politics is complex, where the military wielded ultimate power for decades and where “Secular Kemalism” was and still is the dominant social standard, especially because he has consistently opposed both throughout his career as a politician.  Many have constantly levelled charges of a secret Islamist agenda nurtured by Erdoğan, calling him an enemy of secularism, and evidence has pointed to examples where that argument can be made. Erdoğan has also been rather trigger happy in jailing dissidents from the media and the old Ataturk guards in the army who remain defanged, a very unpopular policy.

Yet he has survived three terms in office with each successive win increasing the margin of victory which remains unprecedented in the republic's history. Even the recent Gezi Park protests hasn’t dented his popularity enough. A recent poll concluded that he was still popular with 50% of the respondents, though clearly the numbers have been seen to be trending downwards year on year. It’s a fascinating story with many parallels to our own politics.

This however doesn’t paint the entire picture. The protest in Gezi Park is the culmination of a seething section of the Turkish republic spanning all classes, including Erdoğan’s own voters that are rebelling against him; it is increasingly being ill-hidden primarily as a result of his authoritarian moves on the republic; weird public pronouncements bordering on racism; direct association with financial benefactors of his decisions; hiring of the type of people he surrounds himself with, like the recent appointment of Yiğit Bulut as his chief advisor.

Bulut is the same man who claimed that the Gezi Park protests are the result of Erdoğan’s enemies using telekinesis. It doesn’t help either that Erdoğan has attacked both the ideals of Ataturk and the man himself. What Ataturk perhaps would find offensive is that Erdoğan continues to mock institutions of secularism, in repealing old laws guarding those values that have existed since the abolishment of the Ottoman Sultanate and the Caliphate that Ataturk oversaw himself.

Therefore, Erdoğan’s plan to rebuild an Ottoman barracks in Gezi park, the site of a 1909 attempt by the Ottoman sultan Abdul Hamid II (also known as the Grim) to stop the liberal reforms that eventually led to Ataturk’s modern republic is extremely controversial, causing to some extents the protests we see today. In another unwise move, Erdogan has named Istanbul’s “third bridge” over the Bosphorus, linking Europe and Asia, after an Ottoman despot who slaughtered tens of thousands Turkmens and Kurds back in the 16th century. Critics have labelled these decisions as part of a sinister policy that poorly attempt to pull back Turkey to a pre-Ataturk era where religion governed Turkish society very strictly and Islamic laws ruled the land.

In my assessment of the situation, I differ somewhat to the critics’ opinion of Erdoğan and most of the western coverage of this current Turkish predicament. It’s not an Islamisation or re-Islamisation problem. In my visit to Turkey in January this year, I gauged from discussions with locals that their problem wasn’t with the moves made by Erdoğan that were informed by his religious views (the country is a Muslim one after all) but the way in which he was unilaterally imposing them on everyone.

What bothers them is the authoritarian streak. “The unimpeded intrusion into people’s lives” is what one young double first class degree holding taxi driver who voted for Erdoğan. expressed to me. For example, the recent law on the ban on alcoholic drinks has, for instance, caused a major row in Turkey. The problem it caused was not because of the ban on drinking per say because 80% of Turkey’s population doesn’t drink but the attempt further illustrated the idea that Erdoğan would do anything and everything to legalise his personal agenda whenever the opportunity presented itself, even if the problem was small or non-existent.

It also showed that he wasn’t shy to ban anything opposed to his personal positions about how society should conduct itself. This is a personality trait that has begun to bother Turkey. That intrusion or limiting of choice is ringing alarm bells for many who fear the intrusions will only get more audacious with time.

A manager at a local hotel where I stayed explained to me in a discussion: “Turkey because of Ataturks formula of governance didn’t attempt to throw out Islam from existence as Erdoğan’s supporters like to preach. Look around,” he told me, “Do you see an un-Islamic Turkey?” He went on to add: “What Ataturk created was an environment where stability flourished, where education was paramount and distractions to those goals were reduced in the public eye. He (Ataturk) believed that was the way forward and what Turkey is today is because of that stability and formula Ataturk installed and promoted. Erdoğan’s policies are dangerously informed by Neo-Ottomon dreams of a larger Turkish empire and it’s precisely what Ataturk spent his life fighting.”

Another friend of mine on email right after the first protests broke in Gezi Park stated: “It’s unfair to even think of Erdoğan in the same breath as Ataturk because the latter wasn’t a dictator and his ideals being expressed in protests today is testament to the lasting legacy he left behind as a leader even 70 odd years after his death. Erdoğan on the other hand is overestimating his position in history because of ballot wins and that over-playing of his hand is going to land him in trouble and drag this country into a dark corner. Even from the grave Ataturk is winning because his ideals fight for progress and freedom of the Turkish people and Erdoğan’s doesn’t. Ataturk was never considered a dictator and Erdoğan is increasingly acting like one.”

This was a telling statement which demonstrated to me that not only do the Turkish people understand the problem but were actively fighting now to correct the path the country was heading towards. In this way it is a very different fight against the establishment that we are seeing in Turkey today as opposed to ones in Egypt and Brazil.

This is a battle that has a far clearer goal, to correct the over-empowerment of government and to protect encroachment on modern Turkish heritage. A guaranteed democratic right, some would argue, in fighting against which, in the context of Turkey, Erdoğan will eventually lose. Realising this Erdoğan has stated publicly that he is hoping to initiate a more powerful Presidential system in place of the present one via a constitutional amendment that mirrors the US system of electing a president with an eye to running for that office in 2014. This in my opinion is very dangerous for Turkey and as such worth the present fight the people are waging against their own government. With numbers growing country-wide, protestors chanting that they are part of the new Ataturk army and Erdoğan drawing battle lines in doing as he pleases against them. Turkey is bracing for an uncertain future. Setting Erdoğan’s self-destructive behaviour aside for a moment, it’s not hard to see why many people in Turkey are beginning to realise a sharply declining delight with their new father.

Top Brokers