Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

‘Jamaat is certainly not anti-capitalist’

Update : 04 Feb 2016, 06:13 PM

Maidul Islam is Assistant Professor in Political Science at the Centre for Studies in Social Sciences, Calcutta. The book, Limits of Islamism, is a comparative analysis of the ideological articulations of Jamaat-e-Islami in contemporary India and Bangladesh; the prospects, weaknesses, and limits of Jamaat remain the concerns of the book.

One of the Jamaati claims, and this is also true for the Muslim Brotherhood and other such organisations, is that they claim a certain ideological continuity of tradition, through their citing and readings and selections of the past. How far is this kind of projection true?

It is true that both Jamaat and the Muslim Brotherhood often claim a certain ideological continuity of Islamic tradition through their uncritical engagement with the Islamic texts and selected readings from Islamic history, which they regard as the “golden past” or “true golden age.” However, that neither makes them pre-modern nor anti-modern because, to be modern, one has to believe in certain values and think in a particular philosophical manner.

Many Muslims believe in such pasts (sometimes authentic events of the past, while in some cases, distorted narratives about the past). Jamaat has to operate in such a context where there is an Islamic audience who believe in such “Islamic” pasts.Revisiting the past does not mean that the past could be produced now for it is impossible to experience a Medinian regime of the 7th century in the 21st century. If an “Islamic state” is ever established in any part of the world, it would be certainly different from 7th century Arabia. Mimicry or imitation is bound to be a process of distortion than reproducing an original form.

What are the main political, tactical, and ideological differences between the Jamaat-e-Islami in the Indian Union and Bangladesh? Can we argue these differences in terms of Muslim-minority versus Muslim-majority context or would that be generalising too much?

For any political party, the context and the sense about its prospective audience is important. The Muslim minority context in India and the majority context in Bangladesh is important to keep in mind. In India, the Jamaat is a weaker social organisation. Recently, a section of its leadership has formed the Welfare Party of India. In contrast, the Jamaat has been an important player in contemporary Bangladeshi politics.

In India, the Jamaat has dropped the idea of establishing an “Islamic state” and has almost accepted the Indian version of secularism while demanding minority rights. In India, the Jamaat is relatively aligned with the secularist and left-wing forces unlike in Bangladesh, where secularists and leftists are almost treated as enemies by the Jamaat. In India, the Jamaat is clearer about its opposition to neo-liberal capitalism while proposing an Islamic welfarist model.

In Bangladesh, the Jamaat is more ambiguous towards neo-liberalism because it has high stakes in an economy governed by the logic of neo-liberal capitalism.In fact, within a neo-liberal framework, the Jamaat has grown in Bangladesh with huge investments in many sectors as one finds in some scholarly investigation on the political economy of Islamism in Bangladesh.

Varied Islamist expressions in different contexts is important to investigate, given the fact that a section of the media and academia often presents “Islamism” as a homogenous ideology.

The almost revolutionary social and world order change that Jamaat promises to its faithful, positing capitalism as something it is NOT -- you argue against this claim and promise. Could you explain?

Maududi and his followers argued that Islam prescribes neither capitalism nor socialism as it is a “middle path.” If capitalism is a system of wage labour and private ownership of major means of production, then Jamaat is certainly not anti-capitalist because it strongly defends private property rights. Even if Jamaat’s proposed “Islamic economic system” is opposed to an interest-based economy, it is certainly not opposed to extracting surplus value and its other different forms: Namely, profit and rent.

The Jamaat has no substantive proposal to alter the capitalist mode of commodity production and exchange by money (as Marx noticed in capitalist market economy) with an alternative “Islamic” mode of production and exchange. So, the claim of Jamaat in its ideological literature for opposing capitalism is a false claim. 

What is the ‘alternative’ that Jamaat offers, at least theoretically, and what are its practical limits? Is it really something alternative in some fundamental sense?

Theoretically, Jamaat offers an alternative Islamic socio-economic and political system. However, such a vision of an Islamic state at present is nothing short of an agenda of interest-free welfare capitalist model. It is, at best, a form of regulated capitalism.

The additional dimension of interest-free economy and prohibition of certain goods and professions does not prevent it from becoming a capitalist economy because the Islamic system proposed by the Jamaat ideologues perfectly gels with the logic of capitalism.

When neo-liberalism has become hegemonic, any proposal of a welfare and regulated capitalism might sound like an alternative but it is certainly not an alternative to capitalism as such.

In that sense, although Jamaat promises an alternative, it is actually not a fundamental alternative. This is an important limit of Jamaat. The practical limits of Jamaat in Bangladesh is that its project of an imagined Islamic utopian state has less takers and it has consistently lost support from the 1990s. 

Top Brokers