Meet Sadhona Biswas. The daughter of a farmer, she was a student of humanities at a local school in Gopalganj’s Kashiani upazila. On the night of May 30, hours after the SSC test results were published, she committed suicide by taking poison, apparently because she had failed in mathematics.
In Fedi village of Narail, 16-year-old Tahidul Islam, a student of Birshreshtha Noor Mohammad Secondary School, died after he hanged himself from a mahogany tree near his house on the same day.
The school’s head teacher said Tahidul was the school’s only candidate among 24 who failed the tests.
Sadhona and Tahidul were among 147,278 students who failed this year’s SSC tests under eight education boards. A total of 93,631 students got GPA 5 under the eight boards.
Results of SSC and HSC exams (both are high-stakes, standardised tests) in Bangladesh generate massive news coverage. We see information-packed newspaper reports that accompany analyses, graphs, tables, and photos of jubilant pupils as well as their guardians and teachers, all celebrating the scholastic accomplishment. But the way suicides of pupils like Sadhona and Tahidul are reported suggests that these are not too much of an issue.
Does that mean these are isolated incidents? Make no mistake -- every year, after results are out, there are youngsters like Sadhona and Tahidul who destroy their precious lives just for failing exams. They make the difficult choice to be in graves rather than taking a second chance to see if they can pass and improve scores.
What we are losing at the untimely death of these youngsters can never be accurately measured. They could have become brilliant engineers, best-selling authors, social reform leaders, respected scientists, celebrated entrepreneurs, and accomplished journalists. The possibilities were endless until they chose to kill themselves.
It is a pity that there is no official census on the number of Bangladeshi students who committed suicide because of exam failures (as if those lives did not matter). Noted columnist Syed Abul Maksud wrote last year that at least a thousand students killed themselves in the sub-continent in the last century, and many parents also died of heart failure because the agony was too great for them to withstand.
This is alarming, and we should be afraid of this epidemic as these deaths are manifestations of how our overly sincere efforts to build an educated society have facilitated the birth of a terrifying trend that we have gradually lost control of.
And our bright youngsters are becoming its innocent victims.
Our education policies explain well how it all started. Firstly, we offer students nothing other than standardised tests to measure how well they are doing in school. Test scores have been routinely used to pit students against each other, preparing the ground for fierce academic competition.
Undeniably, test-based education continues to be a more competitive activity. Gone are the days when results would be published in divisions.
The system saw even more changes concerning the GPA. In the early years of the system, only a handful of students scored GPA 5, but before long, we saw a dramatic surge in the number of top scorers. Pass rates have also risen almost consistently over the last 10 years, rising from 52.57% in 2005 to 92.67% in 2014 in SSC and from 59.16% to 75.74% in HSC over the same period.
When competition and test-based performance were playing their parts in the education system, we also enforced harsh penalties to deal with failures. In our society, nothing can bring more condemnation, disapproval, and also corporal punishment for teenage pupils than failure in exams. The study-crazed culture has persuaded students to accept that exam failures should never be an option, and they must pass each and every test at any cost. This attitude has become deeply entrenched across the society.
We thought ensuring academic competition while employing disgrace and punitive measures for failures would strengthen students’ grit to achieve high scores. But it entailed the collateral damage that we perhaps never thought would surface -- our students have picked up the fallacy that exam failures mean the ignominious end of a promising life and is therefore not worth living because there is no hope and no room for improvement.
Another point worth mentioning is that our students learn many powerful lessons such as “failure is the pillar of success” and “ekbar na parile dekho shotobar” (try a hundred times if you fail the first time) in school. The story of how Scottish king Robert the Bruce was inspired in a cave by seeing a spider’s repeated attempts to make a web and then went on to defeat the English at the Battle of Bannockburn is popularly used by students in essays on perseverance.
But they are barely motivated (read: Allowed) by teachers and parents to practice these lessons in reality. What happens then? They feel the Scottish monarch can try several times to win but they cannot. They also feel that ekbar na parile dekho shotobar is just a poem to be memorised, not a principle to be guided by. This is one of the biggest failures of our education system. There is no shortage of impressive, useful content that our school curriculum offers, but the learners can hardly apply those in their lives.
There is no way for unsuccessful pupils to escape punishment resulting from academic failures and leniency. The exclusion they are subjected to because of failure amounts to virtual ostracism. At school, it is common to face corporal punishment and to be humiliated in front of peers. Back home, the situation they find themselves in is all but same. The degree of punishment at home and school may vary, but both are aimed at invoking a sentiment -- you have gone to the dogs and there is no way you can make further progress.
When children, from as early as their kindergarten life, are raised in an environment where failures always result in disapproval, disrepute, and also corporal punishment, it is not surprising that they might harbour extreme thoughts like suicide.
But can excessive academic pressure and the fear of test failures increase suicidal tendencies? Take the case of South Korea, which is home to famed brands such as Samsung and LG. Over the past few decades, South Korea has transformed its economy while raising the level of educational attainment to enviable heights.
Korean students outperformed many developed nations, including the US, England, and Canada, in the 2012 PISA (Programme for International Student Assessment) test administered by the Paris-based think tank OECD (Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development), securing the fifth position in math and reading, and seventh in science. America, known as one of the education superpowers, ranked 36th in math, 28th in science and 24th in reading, while Shanghai topped the list in all three areas.
But the rise of South Koreans to this praiseworthy level has come at a heavy price. The country, according to 2012 OECD data, has one of the highest suicide rates (29.1%) among the developed countries, and the numbers are especially high among youngsters.
The high incidence of suicide has often been attributed to the lifelong pressure pupils face to do better academically. South Korean students study unusually longer hours, attend cram schools (known as hagwons) after regular school hours, and routinely sleep in classrooms in the day because they do not get much sleep at night.
While many in the world praised their education system, South Koreans themselves have admitted that there is too much pressure on children to succeed, and pupils participate in the race to be academically the best from early on. There are high levels of depression and stress among students, largely caused by the hyper-competitive education system.
The love for educational enlightenment helped South Koreans build a highly educated nation, with its students dominating league tables, and a large economy, which was the world’s 12th largest in 2011, but now they understand the price they have paid.
A February 2014 survey by the Korea Health Promotion Foundation, an affiliate of the Finance Ministry, showed that just over half of South Korean teenagers had suicidal thoughts that year, while nearly one in three said they felt very depressed.
Over 40% of the respondents said school pressure and future uncertainty concerned them the most.
US journalist Amanda Ripley quoted then South Korean Education Minister Lee Ju-Ho in her 2013 book The Smartest Kids in the World, a New York Times bestseller, as saying that Americans see a bright side of the Korean education system, but Koreans are not happy with it.
“The country created a monster as the education system had become overly competitive, leading to an unhealthy preoccupation with test scores,” the minister said.
While the deaths of Sadhona, Tahidul, and other unsuccessful pupils in Bangladesh do not resemble South Korea’s disturbing suicide statistics, there is no reason to disregard the similarity in the two cases. If academic pressure and exam failure takes away promising young lives, there can hardly be any compelling reason to continue the current expectations of our children.
We must fight this academic monster before it takes even more lives.



