Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

It doesn’t have to be a race

Update : 29 May 2015, 06:44 PM

There is little scope for brushing aside the fact that the education system in Bangladesh is overly characterised by competition. Such competition has been revered for long in our society, and has been vigorously promoted as a catalyst that positively affects learning and dramatically increases student performance.

The recent years saw a marked rise in the number of students who scored GPA 5 in the SSC and HSC examinations. The explanation, especially by politicians, has been that students are learning well and are increasingly performing better every year. The results have been viewed as outstanding achievements of the government, educational institutions, and also pupils.

But while we rejoiced at the students’ report cards, we have failed miserably to consider the academic and emotional price students pay to be competitive, especially in their formative years, and remain so.

From a very early age, children are taught that what they will learn will mostly be used to put their abilities to the test in order to determine how they have performed against their peers in assessments, primarily standardised tests in each grade, as well as the national board exams.

Instead of systematic efforts made to familiarise children with formal schooling in ways that will help them develop inquisitive minds and a natural passion for learning, the parents apparently consider it their rightful duty to drill the idea of competition into these youngsters.

Children as young as five or six are told that it is about how good or bad they are in producing test scores in relation to their fellow classmates. It is like telling them that they are here in the world only to be the best among all other students in the class when compared academically.

Going to school and attending lessons with other children while engaging in games is a substantial part of how children learn to socialise. They make friends and interact with their peers in academic settings. This is the time when they need to be in a playful, fun environment as they cope with the scholastic world.

What they are offered instead are carefully crafted messages of rivalry that are aimed at preparing them for competition. This is how the tendency to contend for academic triumph is firmly established in children’s minds.

In every step of learning, you are working towards the goal to do well in tests even if it means you do not enjoy lessons or have difficulties in comprehending the topic -- this is the harsh message children receive after they enroll in school.

Intense pressure to compete with others keeps growing as children are promoted to the next grade each year. When still in their teens, they take SSC and HSC exams. Parents only want to see that their children have achieved GPA 5.

Not being able to outperform peers, even if the child has passed the subjects by getting acceptable marks, is deemed a defeat, with consequences such as lowered chances of getting accepted at public universities or being hired for jobs. 

Does this recipe for stiff academic competition produce any laudable outcomes? David Johnson, emeritus professor of educational psychology at the University of Minnesota, reviewed all the studies they could find on the subject of competition from 1924 to 1980. 65 of the studies found that children learn better when they work cooperatively as opposed to competitively, eight found the reverse, and 36 found no significant difference.

Teresa Amabile, who is the Edsel Bryant Ford Professor of Business Administration in the Entrepreneurial Management Unit at Harvard Business School, in a study, asked children to make silly collages. Some did it to compete for prizes and some did not.

Seven artists then independently rated all the works, and it was found that those who worked with the aim to win produced collages that were much less creative -- less spontaneous, complex, and varied -- than the others.

Many researchers have concluded that pupils do not learn better when education is turned into a competitive struggle. The struggle to be the “Number One” has been found to be a distraction.

Children at the early stages of life should learn and study in order to acquire knowledge that will later help them develop critical thinking skills. The ultimate goal of education is getting pupils to learn. Where is the place for education if there is no learning taking place?

But the over-emphasis on competition in our society hinders real learning, because children begin zeroing in on the quest to outdo others and become accustomed to disregarding the true significance of education -- something more alarming than not being able to land a good job.

Competition has another major drawback: Rote learning. In Bangladesh, the sole criterion to measure student attainment is scores in the standardised tests. Thus the goal to compete against peers with the only aim of becoming the best, in effect, forces pupils to aggressively make rote learning their best friend. They know if they can learn the lessons only by heart, they can reach their target without fretting about the depth of the contents. 

Rote learning is outright dangerous because it puts an end to creative thoughts, destroys natural curiosity to learn, and also kills the ability to apply the knowledge to analyse real-life situations. 

So, what can parents do to prevent this problem from getting worse? An effective step for reducing competitive attitudes at home is to consciously avoid using words that promote direct competition, and instead construct messages that inspire a personal pursuit of excellence among children without the worry over what others are doing or trying to achieve.

“You are not doing better/must do better than X” can be replaced with statements like “You did quite fine, and more efforts on your part could reward you with a performance boost” or “I am happy that you are making progress, and I also believe there is more to explore in your studies that will take you to the next level of understanding and achievement.”

This seemingly negligible change in conversation can actually make a world of difference in the minds of children regarding how they view school and how they perform there. Such a push for getting better also helps them grow their confidence, and increases their thirst for knowledge.

But children can still feel competitive if they see that they have fared badly in exams in proportion to their peers. In such cases, parents, instead of reprimanding them, should tell them that there is always a second chance for betterment. Positive feedback can work wonders for young children.

Considering the extent of damage done to children already, it is high time that we stopped the madness about academic competition and worked to build a society free from this unhealthy component. 

Top Brokers