Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Denying Bangladesh

Update : 19 Sep 2014, 07:37 PM

The lands that are now Bangladesh are, as is still widely recognised, an amalgam of historic territories. Gangaridai, Arakan, Tripura, Assam, Bengal, and the names of the kingdoms that preceded Bengal, amongst them all; names that emerge from the mists of the true history of Bangladesh. And there are many more.

There is nothing unusual in this. Britain, for example, can discern such as Wessex, Northumbria and Dalriada, to name but a few, in the conglomerate that is the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland today. Indeed, there is scarcely a nation in the world that has not enjoyed the same pattern of development.

Why then, I often wonder, is Bangladesh so ready to deny its own history; a history rich enough to be the envy of, even, a Briton like myself.

It was an ancient centre of trade, renowned around the ancient world for its commerce and military strength. And it has an astonishing cultural history as, perhaps, the only nation in the world to have nurtured the birth of at least three great religions, and perhaps a fourth, as well as being a significant element in the propagation of a fifth.

The reflection regularly passes through my mind, especially when researching aspects of that unique heritage.

Looking for examples of famous Bengalis from the 18th century, I find that Google can offer me a very wide assortment of cultural icons, almost all of whom were both Hindu, and born in the land that is now West Bengal.

That unbelievable premise is not, of course, a reflection on either Muslims, or the lands of Bangladesh. It is, simply, a reflection on the academic deficit in Bangladesh.  Clearly, it reflects, rather, little research, less publication, and poor use on online opportunities, in Bangladesh, compared to India.

The widespread neglect, even denial of its own rich past is, sad to say, often combined with a widespread sense of victimhood.

Generally, the finger of suspicion for the ills that have befallen the peoples who now occupy the lands of Bangladesh, by passes their own forty four years of opportunity to recover from the desolation left behind by Pakistan, over whom that finger of blame also passes with ease, coming to rest on the British period.

The earliest blame seems to have been earned by the East India Company, who apparently laid the foundations for the destruction of the wonders of the Mughal period, and all that went before.

Even I have been enticed, in the past, to appreciating the likely hood that personal rapacity of East India Company employees was to blame for example, for the infamous famine of 1770/71, although most accusers remain blissfully unaware of the very existence of that horror that it is believed saw 10 million victims, and recall only that of 1943. After all, as I well know from my own experience as Head of Aquisitions and Development for a large British multinational in the 1970s, takeovers are delicate processes, with considerable risks attached.

Research , however, that I casually undertook recently, found me a fascinating piece online , published by University of Chicago, written by Rachel Fell McDermott. Her research was, in fact, into a sidelight; the development of the Durga Puja in late eighteenth century Bengal.

Examining the economics of the administrators of early eighteenth century Bengal, in which, of course, a great deal of Delhi influence had already been superseded by a fairly autonomous Nawab in Bengal, she identified, perhaps, a considerable weakness in the agricultural superstructure of what were, after all, exceedingly fertile agricultural lands.

I have always wondered how administration of such fertility could have so rapidly collapsed following the 1765 grant of Diwani rights, that famine became the consequence.

Well, it appears the mal administration may have predated those grants. The rapacity of the, largely Muslim Zamindari, it seems, in fact, had a lot to answer for.

Whilst, being  British, and associated with the East India Company, one of her sources, with perhaps suspect objectivity, Robert Orme, the 18th century historian, notes in his well reputed work, “under the nawabs everyone in the property hierarchy, from ryots, village heads, zaminders, and faujdars up to the nawabs themselves, looked with fear upon the jealousy of their immediate superiors. The nawab (the Nawab of Bengal) fixes his eye on every portion of wealth that appears in his province.”

McDermott continues, reporting on her research, “Murshid Quli Khan (1704-1725) was a notoriously strict revenue collector, punishing those who failed to comply; even under the more tolerant Alivardi Khan (1740-1756), the Bengali economy began to be impoverished, with the rajas assets increasingly squeezed. The Burdwan raja, Tilakcand, even wrote to the East India Company in 1757, on the eve of Plassey, “By the rapaciousness of the Government nothing is left to me. These three years I have no power left to me in my country, and my own servants refused to obey me. But by the blessings of God by your coming the country shall flourish, and all men have their hearts at ease. I hope in God your power will be as great as I could wish it, and that you may be good to everyone. On this depends my own welfare.”

However, her research moved her next to report, “Even after Plassey, the puppet nawab, Mir Kassim (1760-1763) had several prominent zaminders jailed, tortured and killed.”

The seeds, it seems, of that horrific famine, long blamed on the Company, may, in fact, have been home grown. Which is not, of course, to exonerate the company from Mir Kasim’s reported behaviour amongst other errors.

I dwell on this alternative reading of the famine, and of the reported weakness of the Company’s behaviour, not to assert a correction, but to point out, what every historian knows, that there are usually two sides to every story, and scholarship demands detailed research and evaluation of the evidence.

As I have worked my way, albeit, to put it mildly, somewhat superficially,  through over three thousand years of the complex and really quite breathtaking history of these remarkable lands that are now Bangladesh, the paucity of real scholarship has astonished, and depressed me.  After all, this heritage is potentially worth both millions of jobs and billions of dollars!

The Spanish writer and philosopher, George Santayana, is famous for his observations, including the depressing, “Only the dead have seen the end of war;” but his most famous is, perhaps appropriate now, “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.”

Few Bangladeshi’s, perhaps, can be faulted for forgetfulness. They have never investigated their past, so know little of it, but when, proud as the majority claim to be, of their nation, and their Islamic faith, their failure to appreciate the amazing grandure of the reality,  of their own, unique history of both, is even more depressing.

The denial, even, of Islamic history  is regrettable. For such a vistor as I to be told that Hindu, Jain and Buddhist histories are of no interest in modern Bangladesh, “because we are an Islamic nation” both belies the Constitution, and appears to deny the Prophet’s famous injunction to his followers to seek knowledge, even unto China. What part of that injunction permits the denial that the Muslims arrived, in Bangladesh, almost without doubt, during the lifetime of the Prophet.

These are, of course, but two examples of  neglect and wilful denial, an ignorance that diminishes Bangladesh today. A tragedy for a nation with so much heritage to boast.

Top Brokers