Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

The end of material want?

Communism is a fine goal -- but socialism and planning aren’t he way to get there

Update : 01 Sep 2019, 12:42 AM

It's entirely possible to critique Marxism as a political philosophy, something ably done by Anupam Debashis Roy in this newspaper just recently. It's also necessary to consider it as an economic theory, a pathway to development, and as that it stinks.

The problem is that it simply doesn’t work or perhaps we should go on and actually read what Marx in fact said about economics and follow that path, rather than what people have spent the last century saying he said.

One thing to note is that Marx does get rather a lot of his economic analysis correct. There's an explanation for that too, the bits he did get right he lifted from Adam Smith and David Ricardo. 

As the not quite a joke has it, all of economics is either a footnote to Smith or wrong so Marx was at least starting in the right place.

But then there's the bit that people say Marx said and what he actually did. The contention is that communism is desirable which, taking what Marx actually said as the goal is true. He means the end of material want, the end of economic scarcity. 

This would be a nice thing to have, a nice thing to happen. The bit that is then said is that socialism is the path to this desirable goal. This part is wrong and we spent much of the 20th century testing the proposition. 

The historical point is that there were two strands that became intertwined. That goal and the then commonly fashionable belief that scientific socialism -- meaning a planned economy -- would be the path to it. 

It wasn't that outrageous a belief, to be fair. This chaos of markets and competition can seem wasteful. Why not apply these new -- they were new then -- scientific principles to tackling this same task of allocating resources to create value and thereby do better?

There were those who argued against this being possible -- Mises, later Hayek, and so on -- but while they were correct, they were theoretical propositions. Both that planning would work better and also that it wouldn't. 

The thing is we then tested the two propositions. For much of that 20th century, we had largely to entirely-planned economies -- the Soviet and socialist places -- and largely to entirely-free market-based societies. 

And when we looked east over the Brandenburg Gate in 1989 we had the result of the largest natural experiment yet conducted in economics. 

Market systems are vastly more efficient at creating value, income, and wealth than planned economies. We tested it and the scientific socialists were wrong, the free market liberals were correct.

It's important that we understand what Marx himself was actually saying. The details of what communism would be -- other than that end of scarcity -- were all rather vague. And the details of how we'd get there were more than just a little “handwavey.”

Except for the one important point that most of the 20th-century socialists didn't grasp -- for Marx, communism comes when scarcity is abolished. The how we get there was, to Marx, through the immense productive powers of industrial capitalism.

No, really, read Das Kapital again. It isn’t saying that the Politburo commanding where the factory is, or what it produces, is the path to the end of material scarcity. Rather, that when unlimited production has arrived then communism will be possible.

And then we have that scientific test, that century of experience between the two systems.The free-market liberal one creates that wealth faster than the planned method. 

Thus, to be a free market capitalist is to be bringing the arrival of true communism closer. Now, I prefer the free-market liberal bit simply because I'm a liberal -- freedom and liberty, including economic such, are the things that matter to me. 

But imagine that you are a communist, you think that material wealth, such to the point where there simply is no shortage, is what is required and desired. 

That’s the end goal -- you should be supporting whatever method of economic organization gets us there. That is, to be a communist these days, you too should be a free-market liberal.

Yes, it's an odd way of looking at things but it does have the merit of actually being true. In Marx’s analysis, communism is the end of material scarcity. A reasonable enough goal, of course, the only subsequent question being, well, how do we get there? 

As Marx himself pointed out, it is capitalism that has the productive powers so that’s the system we should use to get to that goal. As history, that last century, shows us, this is empirically proven as well.

Or as we might put it, communism is just fine as a goal, it’s just that socialism and planning aren’t the way to get there.


Tim Worstall is a Senior Fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.

Top Brokers