This newspaper tells us that we should not only save the tigers, but we’re also told how to do it. Essentially, take the humans out of the Sundarbans and also diversify the breeding stock by introducing Bengal tigers from zoo collections, and so on.
This is entirely right but it’s also the tactics, not the strategy. That strategy of how to solve the greater problem, how to save both the environment and the megafauna that lives in it, is rather simpler -- get rich.
It’s an obvious observation we can make: The richer parts of the world tend to be cleaner than the poorer. Above a certain minimum of course -- with true and absolute destitution no one has anything to litter with.
But the water in the Thames in London is cleaner than that in the Buriganga as it passes through Dhaka’s tannery district. One reason for this is that a richer society will be willing to pay more to clean up the mess of being richer.
We even have a formal name for this, the environmental Kuznets Curve. That basic insight being that doing things -- doing things being a useful definition of having an economy -- causes pollution.
So, as a society becomes richer, that is does more things, there is more pollution. We thus get dirtier as we get richer.
But as we do become richer we spend out increased wealth on different things. A superior-good -- luxury good -- is something we spend a higher portion of our income on as our incomes rise. A normal one the same amount, an inferior less.
As we become richer we spend less on merely rise for lunch and more on meats, other grains, bread, and potatoes. The subsistence food in a society is, above a very low income, an inferior good.
We also note that, above a certain income, one not far off from where Bangladesh is right now, the environment becomes a superior or luxury good. We actively spend more of our incomes on having that cleaner country around us.
More on filters for the power station chimneys, clean the waste-water more before it rejoins the river.
The environment becomes cleaner as we get ever richer simply because that’s what we desire as we do get richer. The air in London, for example, is cleaner than it has been since about 1500 when we first started to burn coal.
This is not the only thing happening though. Getting richer is also known as becoming more efficient in our use of resources. This is what the process is -- we use land better, we gain more from the same amount of land, we’re richer.
For any given amount of land, we become richer by using it more efficiently. This is also true of any other economic resource, copper, fuel, and people’s labour.
So, what happens when we use that land more efficiently? We need to use less of it to gain the same amount of food of course.
That means that as we’re using less land to feed humans, there’s more we can put aside to feed nature -- including apex predators like those beloved tigers.
We can thus say -- and we’d be right in saying so too -- that more efficient farming will save the tiger. Simply because that means we can put aside those Sundarbans for tigers to thrive in.
Note though that we must be specific about this. In order to save the tiger we must economize on the use of land in farming. Not economize on all inputs but on land.
Which means that we cannot use organic farming, the one input that organic requires more of being that land. Instead, we must move to industrial farming -- pesticides, herbicides, chemical fertilizers, and all.
For that’s what industrial farming is, it’s substituting these chemicals for that other input, land.
Which does lead us to an odd conclusion but one that’s true all the same? The way to save the environment, that wildness, is to eradicate it from the fields where we grow our food.
In that manner, we can thus economize on the use of land for agriculture and so leave land aside for the wild to be, well, to be wild in.
The grand overall strategy of saving the environment is for us all to get rich. For those rich places are indeed cleaner than the poorer.
But more than that, the very process of getting richer is us becoming more efficient in the use of inputs into the system, meaning we can leave more for the other forms of life out there.
And as it works out, as it has done everywhere, people do indeed put those newly freed resources to work in preserving that environment.
That this is all entirely contrary to what many environmentalists tell us is unfortunate but it has the merit, unlike what we’re being told by all too many environmentalists, of actually being true.
Tim Worstall is a Senior Fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.



