China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) offers tremendous opportunities in terms of promoting global connectivity with economic integration.
Together with China’s massive engagement abroad in trade, investment, contracts, and political relations, BRI constitutes a geopolitical grand strategy that creates both challenges as well as opportunities for the adjoining countries.
However, BRI’s success will depend upon how the perceived or real strategic and geopolitical objectives and apprehension of the increasing Chinese influence in each of the connected countries are addressed in a transparent and accommodative manner.
BRI as a global project covers 78 countries with nearly a third (30%) of the world GDP and two-thirds (70%) of the world’s population. It covers most of Asia and continental Europe as well as Africa. The mission of the BRI is to advance “global development” through economic integration, connectivity, and investment in infrastructure projects. BRI is also frequently labeled as “globalization with Chinese characteristics.”
Factors like market integration, advancement of technology, and dynamism of demography speak for an irreversible process of globalization. BRI has been often referred to as “globalization 2.0,” with a substitute vision for globalization in which there is supposed to be China’s supreme role in sharing the fruits of its economic development and surplus capability with BRI countries.
All the five pillars of BRI (policy coordination, connectivity, trade, financial integration, and people-to-people contacts) seek to promote globalization. Through the BRI, China is projecting itself as the saviour of globalization.
In 2017, China’s trade with BRI countries had reached a huge $1.44 trillion, of which its import is $666bn and export is $774bn. So far, China has invested over $60bn as Foreign Direct Investments in the BRI countries.
China ranks seventh in the Global Interconnectedness Index. All of that converges for a huge role for China in globalization. BRI is supposed to further emphasize and complement the process of globalization in a different fashion.
Since BRI is a project of global dimensions, the overall global environment will largely affect its implementation and success. The increasing environment of ambiguity in the cooperative international environment at the global level, including the increasing disarray in multilateralism, the undermining of the WTO trade rules, and the rising tide of protectionism and even escalating tension towards the evolution of a full scale trade war, may greatly undermine the success of BRI.
Besides, the rise of populism and nationalism in many countries in the West as well as the East may also undermine the environment of cooperation required for a project of this nature, which is sometimes described as the “project of the century.”
The fissures in global governance, especially the existing malfunctioning system and the alternative global governance mechanism emerging under China’s leadership may bring about new tensions that can hamper the implementation of BRI and its sustainability.
As a mega project, BRI has some challenges including the possibility of losing its momentum as the continued and sustained interest both in China and the participating countries may not be there forever. There is the presence of inherent contradictions between China’s economic nationalism, which seeks the “rejuvenation of the Chinese nation,” versus its espousing of economic globalization to the benefit of everybody.
The political and economic situation in the participating countries may also affect the success of implementation of the BRI projects. In South Asia, there are two main corridors, namely the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) and the Bangladesh China India Myanmar (BCIM) corridor included in the grand connectivity proposal, both of which pass through security-sensitive regions with politically divisive issues.
Another concerning issue is related to the increasing Chinese influence in the form of control of assets that China has taken to offset the inability to pay the debt associated with BRI projects. The famous case of Hambantota Port in Sri Lanka has been cited as a classic case of “debt trap.”
China and the participating countries in BRI must ensure that the propaganda of the “debt trap” and “predatory investment” is not embellished while the genuine issues of debt sustainability are addressed. BRI suffers from what is called the scale of size and scope.
Globalization is also likely to stay because the cost of de-globalization, protectionism, and the “trade war” will be too high. One of the central challenges that undermines globalization is the rising inequality among and within nations. An Oxfam report showed that almost 82% of the world wealth generated in 2017 went to the wealthy 1% of the global population.
Since 2015, a mere 1% of the global rich owned more than half of the global wealth, according to the same report. If the trend continues, the global inequality will further aggravate the pervasive social, economic, and political challenges existing in the world.
The thrust of globalization may shift from a neoliberal approach to a more social and environmental approach. Globalization may find new champions for its defense. This is where the role of China and its BRI project will become important.
China is likely to become the key driver to globalization in the years to come. The BRI can become an alternative model for globalization, in which there is room for more inclusion and sharing of benefits to everyone, as China likes to pledge.
The BRI can also serve as a check on backlash against globalization. It can also help correct some mistakes of neoliberal globalization, which has resulted in winners and losers, and the haves and have-nots.
Ambassador Madhu Raman Acharya is a former career diplomat of Nepal. Ambassador Acharya has served as Nepal’s Foreign Secretary (2002-2005), and Permanent Representative of Nepal to the United Nations (2005-2009).



