Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Oatly Group (NASDAQ: OTLY) up 44% - no, that’s too much for the news value

Sure, the news is good, sales will rise as a result, but not this much

Update : 17 Nov 2023, 02:40 PM

Oatly Group (NASDAQ: OTLY) stock is up 43% on some good news. And yes, it is good news and it’s entirely viable that OTLY stock should rise on that announcement. But 44% on a $300 million market cap company? We’re valuing this news at $150 million in capital value? No, we don’t think so, this is a gross overreaction to this specific piece of news.

OK, so we all know what Oatly does: “Oatly Group AB, an oatmilk company, provides a range of plant-based dairy products made from oats in Sweden. It offers Barista edition oatmilk, oatgurts, frozen desserts, ice-creams, and yogurts; cooking products, including cooking cream, in regular and organic, Crème Fraiche, whipping cream, vanilla custard and spreads in a variety of flavors; and ready-to-go drinks.”

We also know that plant based foods and milks are quite the thing these days. But then we also also know that competition is fierce - because they’re quite the thing these days. Beyond Meat has been having terrible problems, as an example. The real problem that everyone’s got is that no one really has a differentiator. Sure, brand names and all that. But that doesn’t really make a difference in the normal milk market and it’s not making all that much here either.

Oatly Group stock price from Google Finance

So, what is this new news then? “Oatly Group AB (Nasdaq: OTLY)(“Oatly” or the “Company”), the world’s original and largest oat drink company, today announced a new foodservice distribution arrangement in the US with Insomnia Cookies, the beloved brand known for serving warm cookies all day and late into the night. Available at all 250+ locations throughout the US, Oatly 11oz Original and Chocolate Oatmilks are now offered as a great-tasting beverage option alongside Insomnia Cookies’ range of signature warm, delectable cookies, desserts, and ice creams.”

And that’s about it. Sure, we know Insomnia hsa 240 and counting stores, it’s quite the fashionable chain. But a $150 million capital value to Oatly from being available in the stores? We think that’s an overreaction. We think people are getting too excited here and that the effect will fade back.

Top Brokers