Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Pantoro (ASX: PNR) up 23% on what we regard as a very nice, even clever, deal

They’ve sold the rights to something that may not even exist - and sold for cash

Update : 10 Nov 2023, 04:17 PM

Pantoro Ltd (ASX: PNR) shares are up 23% today on a clever little deal. PNR shares are reacting to what we think is an interesting idea. Selling the rights to something that may not even exist and selling them for cash right now. What then adds the cherry on top for us is that we tend to think those things - that don’t yet even exist, if they ever do - are going to be worth much less in the future than they are now. So, yes, we do regard this as value additive.

Pantoro is a gold miner but obviously it’s possible that other minerals exist in the areas it has mining rights. So: “Pantoro Limited (Pantoro) (ASX:PNR) is pleased to announce it has executed a binding agreement with Mineral Resources Limited (MinRes) (ASX:MIN) by which Pantoro divests 100% of its lithium, nickel, copper, and cobalt rights on the Norseman Gold Project for up to A$60 million in cash consideration plus royalties.” We tend to think that cobalt rights aren’t worth very much at present. As we all found out at Jervois Global, current market price mean it’s not worth opening a mine. We tend to think that lithium is going to be worth less in the future than it is now. As we’ve said about Zinnwald, so many people are exploring for, and finding, so much of it that we expect it to move into oversupply.

Pantoro share price from Google Finance

The details: “A$30m upfront cash consideration, payable within five days of execution of the binding term sheet; A$30m deferred payment, payable upon final investment decision to commence a nickel, copper, and/or cobalt mining operation; 2% net smelter royalty on all nickel, copper, and cobalt, recovered; and 0.75% FOB lithium royalty.” Everything except that first $30 million is conditional. Given that there’s been no exploration for those minerals on the site there’s nothing to show that there is in fact anything there. So, in one way we can think of this as just being a freebie $30 million for Pantoro. Of course, it’s going to look a little low if there turns out to be some vast deposit of the target minerals. But there’s still the royalty to console for that.

It is true that this $30 million due now is only 10% or so of Pantoro’s market capitalisation. So it’s not a transformative deal. It is though a nice one and value additive. Perhaps the biggest signal this sends is that management are clever about managing the corporate assets. Turning something that may not exist into cash now is pretty good.

Top Brokers