Whirlpool (NYSE: WHR) stock is down 16% on the results announcement. Which is something of a pity, for the WHR stock’s actual results were good, a significant beat of expectations. The problem is that the forecast for the immediate future was lower than expectations. Which is a nice proof of the base contention that stock prices are not determined by what has happened, nor even by what is happening, but by views of what will happen.
As we say, the actual results were good: “Whirlpool’s net sales grew 3% to $4.93 billion in the third quarter from a year earlier, the company said. Analysts had estimated $4.81 billion, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. Adjusted earnings were $5.45 a share, above the average estimate.” That’s both an earnings and a revenue beat on expectations. We would normally expect the WHR stock price to rise upon that.
It is worth noting that even expectations were weak. 3% is less than consumer price inflation over the period so those expectations were that Whirlpool wouldn’t even be keeping up with inflation. Don;t forget that corporate numbers never are adjusted for inflation, therefore the nominal numbers put forward should be, at a certain level of analysis, be converted into real ones.

Whirlpool stock price from Google Finance
That’s what leads to this worry: “Shares of Whirlpool were spiraling lower after revised earnings guidance from the appliance maker and margin concerns outweighed a quarterly earnings beat.” If sales aren’t keeping up with inflation then each unit sold is making a smaller contribution to those overhead costs, thereby compressing net margins. It’s also true that inflation is, by definition, raising costs at about that inflation rate. Another compression of margins if sales aren’t keeping up with that same inflation rate.
But there was also this: “However, the profit beat in particular was driven mostly by cost saving actions that resulted in about $300M of Y/Y benefit in the quarter. Moreover, WHR management noted that market demand in the Americas was driven entirely by consumers looking to replace their home appliances instead of picking up new ones. "The other side of demand discretionary purchases have been even softer than anticipated as a result of increased mortgage rates and low consumer confidence," Whirlpool (WHR) top boss Marc Bitzer said on the earnings conference call.”
When times are good why not a new kitchen, new appliances? When times get harder such discretionary purchases tend to fade away. And more and harder than many other forms of spending in the economy. It’s also true that higher mortgage rates are reducing housing transactions, another impetus for new appliances.
As we say up at the top, it’s not current results that really determine a stock price, it’s what we all think future results are going to be.



