Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Petra Diamonds (LON: PDL) down 7.5% - the whole diamond market’s down

Those who sell luxury goods can get hard hit when the macroeconomy turns

Update : 06 Oct 2023, 04:40 PM

Petra Diamonds (LON: PDL) shares are down 7.5% today. On the surface the problem for PDL shares is that prices are coming down for diamonds. Which, if you sell diamonds is indeed a problem. But it’s possible to read a slightly deeper problem into what they say as well. Which is that prices are coming down even though supply is being restricted. Which could be an indication of rather deeper problems than just the turn and whims of market pricing.

We’ve looked before at Petra Diamonds: “That’s the bit that worries us. They held back the Tender 6 sale because prices were looking pretty soft. But also insisted that was going to be entirely temporary. Well, yes - but will it be temporary? We remain unconvinced shall we say.

Our reasoning is exactly that macroeconomic background. No, we don’t think the world’s about to tip into recession. However, we do think something else is going on. Consumer discretionary cash ballooned massively over the past few years - lockdown payments and so on and nothing much to spend it all upon. Consumer savings roared up. That’s all now returning to normal. Consumers are dissaving back to more regular levels that is. While we don’t expect GDP to fall to any great extent, therefore neither consumer incomes, the spend down of those extra savings seems to have run its course. We therefore expect mid-market discretionary spending to be weak, even though formal recession is unlikely.”

Petra Diamonds share price from Google Finance

Well, now we’ve results of later sales: “In response to the recently announced two-month moratorium on diamond imports to India commencing on 15 October 2023, Petra has brought forward its Tender 2 sales. In these initial tender results, 344,554 carats, representing c. 75% of the total tender volume, have been sold for a total of US$30.2 million, at an average price of US$88 per carat, including Williamson. These prices are 16 to 18% lower than prices achieved in Tender 1 FY2024 on a like-for-like basis, reflecting prevailing market weakness. The steps taken by major producers to curb supply to the market and the two-month Indian moratorium are expected to bring some much needed stability and support to the market and in turn prices.”

The weakness is continuing that is. And supply restrictions, well, they only work if everyone does it. Which means that Petra needs to as well - thus cutting revenues. We’re not sure this means leaving any investments in the diamond business but we’re not sure theis is the background against which we’d actively enter any such investments.

 

Top Brokers