Harvest Minerals (LON: HMI) shares are down 30%. The immediate cause of the HMI share drop is the publication of the half year report. Which shows sales falling. Which, for a company supposedly in its growth phase, is not one of those things that’s supposed to happen. Now, it is possible that there are cyclical or macroeconomic reasons for this. But it could also be just that, well, organic fertilisers just aren’t really a thing many are interested in. Not that we insist that that’s true, we just put it forward as a possibility.
The announcement: “During the half-year ended 30 June 2023, Harvest sold 7,280 tonnes of its organic fertiliser, KP Fértil®, representing a 74% decrease over the 28,104 tonnes sold in the same period of 2022. While historically the majority of Harvest's annual sales have been achieved in the second half of the year, sales to date in 2023 have remained below internal expectations. This is attributable to a reduction in volume demand by farmers who are less incentivised to boost production whilst crop prices are low and energy prices are high. Accordingly, the Company's 2023 full year invoiced sales target is now 70,000 tonnes of KP Fértil®. Furthermore, the impact on Harvest's financial results has been exacerbated by a reduction in the price of its product, which it has lowered to follow the market and try to encourage farmers to recommence buying.” It is, of course, possible that last year the farmers tried it and this year they don't want it. Which would be more than just a small blow (BTW, worth noting that their sales are mostly Southern Hemisphere, thus the sales timings).

Harvest Minerals share price from Google Finance
It’s the next parts that are possibly doing the immediate damage to the share price. The cash flow is short enough that the directors are now working unpaid. They’ve also not the cash flow to work on their non-organic projects: “Given the scale of activity currently being undertaken at Arapua, the Company did not materially advance either its Sergi Potash Project or its Mandacaru Phosphate Project during the half-year to 30 June 2023.” Well, that’s how we read that - not that they were too busy, but that they couldn’t finance that work.
Our read here is, in the absence of any conflicting information, that farmers just aren’t that interested in organic fertiliser.



