Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Wincanton (LON: WIN) up 11% by getting out from under the pensions problem

It should be easy enough to see why so many companies have closed their direct benefit pensions schemes

Update : 20 Sep 2023, 03:24 PM

Wincanton (LON: WIN) shares are up 11% today, WIN shares rose on the announcement that the company now has the direct benefit pensions scheme fully funded. This is great for Wincanton shareholders as it removes the restrictions upon distributions to them. But the larger point here is probably that we can see, so easily, why so many companies have closed their direct benefit pensions schemes. Because keeping them fully funded is so appallingly expensive, plus the restrictions there are on shareholder distributions if they’re not fully funded.

The announcement: “As at 31 March 2023, the valuation of the Group's defined benefit pension scheme showed an actuarial surplus of £3.9m, compared to an actuarial deficit of £154m at 31 March 2020. The strength of the Scheme means that it is well positioned to meet its obligations to both deferred members and current pensioners; with members' liabilities fully backed by assets on current market assumptions.”

Now pensions valuations are an interesting thing. A rise in interest rates leads to a fall in the amount that must be put aside today to pay for future pensions. Yes, sounds a little odd but we assure you it is so. So the interest rate rises of the last couple of years have done a lot to close that gap. It isn’t that Wincanton has had tho throw £100 million and change in there, it’s that the details of calculating that future cost have changed. 

Wincanton share price from Google Finance

That this is largely due to rising interest rates is why the share price rise on the confirmation is so muted. It was largely obvious that rising interest rates would have this effect. So, some goodly part of the news is already inside the current share price. 

The larger issue though here is that as this result - the pensions are now fully funded - isn’t particularly a result of anything Wincanton has done but is macroeconomic then and therefore we’re going to see similar results from other companies as their pensions funds come up for their 3 year valuations. The interesting speculation is therefore to think about who else might be affected by the same issue? One obvious candidate is BT but there are other companies out there which are heavily weighted down by their pensions funds.

Yes, obviously this is good for Wincanton shareholders - but the interesting game is going to be researching who else is going to gain the same benefit from rising interest rates?

Top Brokers