Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Dick’s Sporting (NYSE: DKS) drops 24% - we should blame inflation or thieves?

Now that shoplifting is often only a misdemeanour maybe it’s that - but it could also be inflation

Update : 23 Aug 2023, 05:11 PM

Dick’s Sporting Goods (NYSE: DKS) stock is down 24% on the results announcement. DKS stock might even have fallen for the reason given in the investor chat - organised gangs of mass shoplifters. As we know theft from retail stores has now become a misdemeanour in some jurisdictions and as will obviously happen thieves respond to incentives. That’s why we get those YouTube videos of gangs steaming through a store. The stories about shop workers being told to not interfere - their safety is more important than trying to catch people for the thefts which they’ll likely not get punished for even if caught.

But it’s also possible to be a little more wary of such claims. Sure, they’re obviously a problem, but still, perhaps a tad more wary. From the investor call at Dick’s: “With this context, I want to take a moment to address our second quarter profitability and our revised 2023 EPS outlook. While we delivered double-digit EBT margin of 10.1%, our second quarter profitability was short of our expectations. This was primarily due to lower gross margin, which, while still significantly above pre-COVID levels, was lower than originally anticipated. Two key factors impacted our second quarter gross margin relative to our original expectations. The first was the impact of higher inventory shrink, organized retail crime and theft in general, an increasingly serious issue impacting many retailers. Based on the results from our most recent physical inventory cycle, the impact of theft on our shrink was meaningful to both our Q2 results and our go-forward expectations for the balance of the year.” Well, yes, OK. Theft will indeed impact upon margins. That’s where we’d expect to see the impact in fact. 

Dick’s Sporting Goods stock price from Google Finance

There is another story available to us though. “The sporting goods retailer reported a 1.8% growth in comparable store sales, a key retail metric that tracks stores that have been open for at least a year. In the same quarter last year, the company shed 5.1%. Dick’s reaffirmed its 2023 comparable store sales outlook in the range of flat to positive 2.0%.” What’s the inflation rate though? For the past 12 months, 3,2%. We expect it to be about that going forward for the next 12 too. 

And recall, corporate numbers are not adjusted for inflation. So, Dick’s real sales, as opposed to nominal, are significantly down. And they’re forecasting a slight fall in the immediate future as well. 

Yes, OK, it could be shoplifting and theft causing the problems. But it’s also possible that inflation is partly to blame. Not directly, but when we adjust these results for inflation then Dick’s is actually shrinking - not something likely to boost a stock price

Top Brokers