Napco (NASDAQ: NSSC) stock is down 45% on the restatement of past results. Or, perhaps, the evidence of slowing growth at the company. Which is amusing because the restatement makes the growth levels look very much better. In fact, growth in net profit is up as a result of the restatement, even as the NSSC stock price then dives 45%. So, a reasonable conclusion is that it’s not the growth rates in the bottom line which are the issue - which makes sense. For a restatement of accounts always worries markets tremendously. If they’ve been getting one line in the accounts wrong then what else is lurking in there? And that’s to be polite about it, the aggressive interpretation is worse, much worse.
As to what’s done at Napco: “Napco Security Technologies, Inc. develops, manufactures, and sells electronic security products in the United States and internationally. The company offers access control systems, door-locking products, intrusion and fire alarm systems, and video surveillance systems for commercial, residential, institutional, industrial, and governmental applications.” Nothing wrong there, it’s a growth industry for sure. It’s those accounts which are the problem. “During the preparation of the Company’s consolidated financial statements for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2023, management of the Company identified certain errors related to the Company’s calculation of cost of goods sold (“COGS”) and inventory for each of the first three quarters of fiscal 2023. Specifically, although the costs of several components fluctuated substantially during fiscal 2023, the Company’s costing procedures did not appropriately account for such fluctuations. As a result, inventories were overstated and COGS was understated, resulting in overstated gross profit, operating income and net income for each period. The Company is in the process of preparing amended Forms 10-Q for each of the first three quarters of fiscal 2023 and intends to file such amendments as soon as reasonably practicable after the restatement process is completed. Based on the information available as of this filing date, the Company estimates that net income for the first three quarters will be revised as follows” - and we get an overstatement of net income for the last 3 quarters of $3.5, $4.7 and $1.3 million.

Napco stock price from Google Finance
The polite way of looking at this is that, well, yes, accounting is difficult and errors are made. But if they’re getting this wrong - really? Stock valuations and COG? - then what else have they got wrong in their numbers? What other shoes are about to drop? The impolite - and very definitely untrue - way is to note that if the numbers were being knowingly and artificially boosted then at some point that effect has to be unwound. And before an audit too - because an audit would show up that cash balances don’t match. There will be some willing to believe in that definitively untrue version.
The problem with accounts restatements is not - or not usually at least - the restatements that happen. It’s the wonderings about what else might be in there needing restatement. That’s at least some part of Napco’s problem.



