Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Hua Hong Semiconductor (HKG: 1347) down 8% - that Shanghai quote hasn’t helped

The domestic quotation doesn’t seem to have helped the company - sanctions are still a problem

Update : 11 Aug 2023, 02:27 PM

Hua Hong Semiconductor (HKG: 1347) (OTCPK: HHUSF) shares are down 8% this morning. 1347 shares don’t seem to have been greatly aided by that IPO and flotation in Shanghai. Yes, obviously, different classes of shares, different potential investor bases but it is usual to see a share price rise after there’s a new quotation - simply because it does increase the number of investors who can legally or practically invest in the company.

This isn’t what has happened at Hua Hong: “Hua Hong Semiconductor, which made the world’s second-largest initial public offering (IPO) this year, made a stellar debut on mainland China’s Star Market despite being issued at twice the price of its Hong Kong-listed shares, buoyed by mainland investors’ zeal for the country’s chip self-sufficiency……That gave Hua Hong’s yuan-traded shares a 148 per cent premium over its Hong Kong-listed stock, lower than the 189 per cent price gap for its bigger rival Shanghai-based Semiconductor Manufacturing International Corporation (SMIC), and reflecting the gap in sentiment between the foreign investors in the Hong Kong market and the domestic investors in the mainland market.”

That’s great, obviously, but it equally obviously seems to have had a detrimental effect on the Hong Kong quotation.

Hua

Hua Hong Semiconductor share price from Google Finance

Now we are rather bear on Chinese semiconductor stocks. Sure, there’s a good business to be had with the older technologies, 20 nm and so on. They are still the nuts and bolts of modern production lines. But the really good margins are in the advanced sectors, 7 nm and moving to 3 nm. And the West has decided - whether rightly or wrongly - to not allow Chinese fabs to buy the equipment necessary to make to those sizes and standards. We can muse that perhaps the Chinese market is large enough to create those techs for itself but we doubt it - and they would be late if they did. So we tend to think that Mainland based fabs are simply going to remain beyond the technological - and margin - curve. 

We have to admit to a certain confusion over the Shanghai quote. Well, perhaps not confusion, disappointment. If we’ve the same thing at two wildly different prices then there should be an arbitrage between them. Buy the Hong Kong stock, sell the Shanghai and wait for the two prices to equalise. But such arbitrages do depend upon the instruments being fungible - which they’re not. Which is, as we say, a great pity because driving trades through a 50% price difference would be a wonderful game. One of the reasons we know the two stocks are not fungible is the existence of the price difference.

Top Brokers