Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Star Entertainment (ASX: SGR) up 18% - Laffer Curves everywhere in taxation

Laffer Curves apply even to betting taxes if the new rate would put the casinos out of business

Update : 11 Aug 2023, 02:23 PM

Star Entertainment (ASX: SGR) (OTCQX: SETY) shares are up 18% today. SGR shares rose on the announcement that the New South Wales tax rates mooted on gambling are to be amended - amended to the point where they do not cripple the business. We can look at this as being just an interesting point about the business, Star, or we can think of the wider implications for politics more generally - it really is possible to tax so much that tax revenues go down.

The original worry was that the new NSW tax rates upon gambling would drive the Sydney operations bust. Now, of course, everyone will complain that higher taxes will do that to them. But sometimes it is also true that this does happen. Taxes become so high that gross margins, thus profits, disappear and thus so does the business. If the business isn’t there then nor is the tax revenue. So, if politics actually believes the business about the incoming tax rates being too high then they might be modified. This is indeed what has happened.

The announcement: “As previously advised, the former NSW Treasurer in the lead up to the NSW 2023 election announced without prior consultation with The Star, a proposed increase in NSW casino duty rates originally intended to take effect from 1 July 2023.

The Star has consistently maintained that the former Treasurer’s proposed duty increase was not sustainable, flawed in its design and, if implemented as originally proposed, would significantly challenge the economic viability of The Star’s Sydney business putting the jobs of thousands of NSW team members in jeopardy.

The Star today announces it has reached an in-principle agreement with the NSW Treasurer,

The Honourable Daniel Mookhey MLC, to amend its duty arrangements with the State.”

star

Star Entertainment share price from Google Finance

As we can see from that share price chart there’s considerable doubt as to whether this is the only problem that ails Star Entertainment. But this does at least buy time to try to solve those other problems. Quite: “Australia's Star Entertainment said on Friday it had secured concessions on casino duty rates in a deal with New South Wales state, putting its shares on track for their best day in 18 years. The cash-strapped company said the agreement will involve a transition plan to give it more time to stabilise operations surrounding its Sydney casino and prevent further job cuts.”

One of the things about Australia, it’s a significantly unionised economy. Thus those worries over the loss of unionised jobs have a significant bearing on politics. That’s just the way the place rolls.

In the longer term of course Star depends on sorting out those other problems too - we’ll have to see.

Top Brokers