Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Proterra (NASDAQ: PTRA) dives 67% on Chapter 11 filing - not enough, should be more

Thinking that there’s going to be equity value after a Chapter 11, well, not often

Update : 08 Aug 2023, 07:33 PM

Proterra (NASDAQ: PTRA) stock dropped 67% after the announcement of their Chapter 11 filing. The big question for equity is always, at this point, is there going to be any value let for the equity? And the correct answer is no. Now, true, that’s not always exactly and wholly true. Hertz did come back from the dead with a value but that was due to extreme circumstances (the used car market turned, making their fleet worth more). The usual outcome of Chapter 11 is the equity going to zero.

At which point Proterra’s stock only falling 67% can be viewed as not enough - it should be more. Maybe folk are hoping this is one of those other times. As we know, the company actually: “Proterra Inc. provides commercial vehicles in the United States, the European Union, Canada, the United Kingdom, Australia, Japan, and Türkiye. The company’s Proterra Powered & Energy business unit offers battery systems and electrification solutions for commercial vehicle original equipment manufacturer (OEM) customers serving delivery trucks, school buses, coach buses, construction and mining equipment, and other applications;”

Now, yers, we all know this is terribly exciting, just like the early years of the automobile, that Earth changing technology. At which point we’ve got to remind ourselves that near every one of those first car makers went bust. More than one many of them too. That’s just what happens with a new technology.

Proterra stock price from Google Finance

Sure, something might arise from the ashes here. But that’s not the same as suggesting there’s going to be value remaining for the old equity: “Apparently, the company is looking to separate the legacy transit bus operations from the battery and charging solutions segment ("Proterra Powered & Energy") and pursue a recapitalization or sale. Regardless of the company pursuing a recapitalization or a sale, a recovery for existing equity holders looks highly unlikely at this point.”

That seems wildly logical to us if we’re honest. The entire point of bankruptcy is that there’s no capital left. Well, if there’s no capital then equity, the capital owning part of the structure, is worth nothing, right?

Given the existence of the meme stock crowd we’d not recommend trying to short Proterra down to zero but that is where we think it’s headed.

Top Brokers