Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

PacWest to merge - those hidden losses had to be revealed, that’s what caused this

As with the other regional banks that got into trouble it’s really rising interest rates plus liquidity needs

Update : 26 Jul 2023, 12:29 PM

PacWest Bancorp (NASDAQ: PACW) stock yo-yoed last night as it both revealed results and also an agreed merger with Banc of California (NYSE: BANC). The details of the deal are available in many places - what matters to us here is why did this happen? For only if we work out why such a perfectly pleasant little bank needed to merge can we work out who else might need to do so in the future. The answer is that it's all about rising interest rates, the hold to maturity book and the dash for liquidity. Another way to put this is that it's about a bank run - as problems with banks are so often about runs.

The deal itself: “PacWest, one of the hardest-hit lenders from the regional banking crisis, has agreed to merge with Banc of California in a sign that the fallout from the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank continues to reverberate across the industry.

The two California-based banks announced the deal on Tuesday, and said buyout groups Warburg Pincus and Centerbridge Partners would also invest $400mn in newly issued equity in the combined bank.” There's also lots of stuff about how this creates a lovely bank in California and so on. Standard PR guff most of it.

The real problem is as we described it before at PacWest: “The specific and major problem at both First Republic and Silicon Valley banks was hidden in the banks' hold to maturity portfolios. The issue here is that these do not have to be marked to market. So, any losses on them - say, a result of increased interest rates in general - don't appear on the bank's P&L or balance sheet. Which is fine, they're not supposed to, as long as that portfolio doesn't get sold. But, if the depositors flee and it has to be sold then the losses get crystalised and it could wipe out the bank's capital. Which is indeed exactly what happened at SVB and probably - we're awaiting the final calculation of this - at FRC.” The trigger here at PacWest was that more of that hold to maturity book has to be sold to maintain liquidity, this crystalising the losses from rising interest rates. 

PacWest Bancorp stock price from NASDAQ

PacWest did all the right this to stage this off, as we've also said about PACW:  “As we've pointed out before PacWest's hold to maturity book is what matters for the capital base of the bank. Currently that seems fine. But that might only be true as long as it doesn't have to sell it off in a fire sale in order to gain liquidity to pay off depositors. So, organising greater liquidity through the FRB in order to not have to crystalise any losses there seems like an excellent prudential idea. But what appears to be happening is that the market is taking that prudential action as evidence that the book might have to be sold off, thereby damaging the capital base. There's really no way out of this, no leap that can be made which resolves the problem. PacWest will muddle along and survive or it won't. And it's the behaviour of depositors which will determine this.”

If you lend fixed rate in a rising interest environment then you're going to lose money. But this is only a problem if you have to crystalise the losses. Which, if the depositors get antsy and you've got to sell some of the hold to maturity book, you will. And that, in a nutshell, is what caused the PacWest problem. Really nothing else than this.

Top Brokers