Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

AppHarvest (NASDAQ: APPH) goes bust - well, we did tell you so, really, we did

Not that we’re happy about the Chapter 11 but we are about having been right

Update : 24 Jul 2023, 05:11 PM

AppHarvest (NASDAQ: APPH) has just filed for Chapter 11. APPH stock has of course fallen, some 35% and change on the news. The sector here, indoor and vertical farming, is something we've written about extensively around the place. And about AppHarvest itself too, even if at another place. Our view being that the entire idea just doesn't work. Farming is something with very large economies of scale. Not only that land is cheap out in the boonies, the water falls free from the skies. Replacing those with expensive land in inner city warehouses just doesn't make sense to us. That's before we even get to the idea of replacing free sunlight with electricity powered light bulbs.

We said this elsewhere about AppHarvest: “The real reason for this is not some theoretical insistence that the world will be better that way. Although it will, the entirety of economics is about the allocation of scarce resources and we always want to allocate them to their highest valued use. But the reason we don't want to invest in people going the wrong way is that they will always be out competed by those doing it the right way. Sure, America eats lots of beefsteak tomatoes. The people who make the best profit producing them will be the people who have the lowest production costs. If we decide we're going to use expensive land and labour while the other guy is going to use cheap land and free rainfall then, well, we've a problem. Because we have to be so many times more efficient than him in order to beat his production costs. If we are that more efficient then happy days of course. But as it seems to be turning out these vertical farms aren't. So, they're not, not really, investable.”

And that was just after their stock issuance on an emergency basis only 4 months back.

AppHarvest stock price from NASDAQ

We made much the same point here about cannabis and Hellenic Dynamics: “Now, the deal today is: “Under the MoU, Hellenic Dynamics will grow and supply medical cannabis flowers from Demecan provided cultivars in an indoor cultivation area of 1,000 square meters capable of producing circa 1,200 kg of medical cannabis flowers per annum under Good Agricultural and Collection Practice ("GACP"). Demecan will then process the delivered flowers in its own EU-GMP facilities for onward sale to the German market.””

Or elsewhere again about Kalera: “What the company does – or perhaps soon will have to stop doing – is vertical farming. This is the idea that we're running out of resources, the farmland's all about to disappear and we should, instead, farm food in the middle of cities – in buildings. This makes sense, perhaps, if you believe all the doom and gloom from the environmentalists. To anyone else this is near insane. Now, clearly that means there's a difference of opinion here and one thing markets are excellent at is clearing up such differences. We measure by money. Does it work, does it not, the measure being whether the output is worth more than the input. Does it, in fact, make a profit?

Our answer here is no.”

Indoor farming just doesn't work. That's why we were bear AppHarvest.

Top Brokers