Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Aqua Metals (NASDAQ: AQMS) down 24% - being honest, we don’t trust them

If the previous business plan included things that we didn’t believe then we tend not to believe the next business plan

Update : 19 Jul 2023, 05:08 PM

Aqua Metals (NASDAQ: AQMS) stock is down 24%. AQMS stock has fallen because they'd issued new stock and that's roiled the market. We, however, are in a rather different position. We're really not sure that we buy the basic Aqua story. We certainly didn't buy it when they were talking about lead recycling. We're not really sure now they're talking about lithium battery recycling instead. But given that the first - the lead - business plan seemed to us to have some holes in its potential veracity we're obviously giving the new plan some side-eye. It may be terribly bad of us that we are doing so but the position has done us well so far. 

As we said back in 2021 about Aqua Metals: “It's obvious that the interest in the stock is febrile. So, trying to predict the short term is impossible, it's a matter of sentiment, nothing else. Take this announcement, a “global partnership” with BASF. That caused a 20% spike in the stock – but what it really is is an announcement that they will buy their reagent from BASF. Well, yes, OK, that's a partnership but not exactly one - “we've got a supplier!”- which should boost the stock all that much. For the longer term I just can't see Aqua Metals becoming a high margin and large market licencer of intellectual property. Assuming that the process works entirely and wholly and has many interested customers the price charged for it would have to be low. A decent return on capital but little economic rent or excess profits. Just because the existence of those would create the competition.” And that was the bull part of the case. The bear was much worse than that.


Aqua Metals share price from NASDAQ

We returned to the subject a year later, when the stock was down 82%. “A year back I said that I just didn't believe the story we were being told here. All of the component units of the story could be entirely true but I just didn't think they added up. Add a year of activity and I believe it all even less I'm afraid. It just doesn't taste right to someone who has been in this metals business. Sorry, but there it is. I'm sure there will be bounces here and there in the Aqua Metals stock price on this or that piece of news. As for the long term I just don't see it going anywhere. Highly opinionated of me but there it is. I can't see what it is that the company has to offer.” Even at 82% off the original price we still didn't believe the story - and that was after they'd announced the switch from lead to lithium batteries as their source for materials to recycle.

It's entirely possible that Aqua has some amazing technology within it. OK, it's vaguely possible it does. But as we - and this is our problem, undoubtedly - don't believe the stories we get from management we don't believe that one either.

Top Brokers