Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Aritzia (NASDAQ: ATZAF) down 24% - The retailer has lost market vision

At least that’s what it is hoped is the problem, that it’s something the company can fix

Update : 13 Jul 2023, 02:07 PM

Aritzia (NASDAQ: ATZAF) (TSE: ATZ) stock is down 24%. The ATZAF stock price fall is as a result of the earnings and trading announcement yesterday. Which was not, as can be gathered, good. The bigger problem here is concern as to whether it's simply management having taken its eye off the ball and got the product mix wrong? Or do we have some difficult competitive position here? Or even are we talking about a macroeconomic swing here? One, perhaps two, of those can be fixed - the third is out of corporate management hands.

 Aritzia is a Canadian retailer expanding rapidly into the US: “Aritzia Inc., together with its subsidiaries, designs and sells apparel and accessories for women in the United States and Canada. The company offers t-shirts and tops, sweaters, shirts and blouses, bodysuits, sweatshirts, blazers, jacket and coats, and dresses; pants, denim, leggings and bike shorts,” and so on through the list of schmutter that women wear. 

 The announced results are not good at ATZAF: “Aritzia Inc. shares plunged after the clothing retailer downgraded its outlook for its 2024 fiscal year, citing macroeconomic pressure on consumers and a lack of “newness” in its products.” Well, yes, but it matters which of those problems actually applies.

 Aritzia stock price from NASDAQ

 If it's simply the stock range getting a bit tired then that's something that management can solve. And this is indeed a problem that Aritzia had a couple of years back and did solve. So, that could be done again.

 The second set of worries is that a lot of their product range is tchotchke. Not essentials for being clothed, but the sort of little additions and extras that people so enjoy buying. OK - but we've Shein and the like looming over the horizon and selling those sorts of things vastly cheaper than any bricks and mortar retailer can. So, it becomes more a battle of how much is retail an experience and how much is it getting stuff? 

 Finally there's those macroeconomic worries: ”as many other retailers were seeing inflation-weary shoppers pull back on purchases. But the company has now begun to see slowing demand, which chief executive officer Jennifer Wong attributed partly to macroeconomic pressures.” If consumers are simply spending less - and this is what the central bank is deliberately trying to engineer - then it's not obvious what cure a retailer has available to it.

 Working out what happens next at Aritzia requires working out what's gone wrong with it here. That's the task to be solved before deciding upon any trading position.

Top Brokers