Charger Minerals (ASX: CHR) shares are down 23% today. CHR shares fell on the announcement of their spodumene pegmatites find. One possible reading of this is just that finding lithium potential just isn't all that exciting any more. After all, so many other people are finding actual lithium that finding the rock that might have some in it just doesn't tempt the juices of the market. It's still a bit odd to have the share price fall on the announcement though. Perhaps there was an expectation that there would be more in this announcement.
What Charger Minerals actually say is: “Spodumene Pegmatites Intersected at the Bynoe Lithium Project” and it's necessary to be precise in reading that. Yes, pgmatites are the type of rock we might find lithium in. Spodumene is the specific mineral within pegmatites that might contain the lithium. But not all pegmatites host spodumene, not all spodumene contains economic quantities of lithium. So, we're being told right mineral in the right rock but that's all. As they go on to point out: “Cautionary Note. Throughout this document Charger refers to “spodumene” or “spodumene-pegmatite”. While the Company is very encouraged by its geological observations, no quantitative assessment of mineralisation is possible at this stage. Drilling widths reported are down-hole and no estimate of true width is given. Further, no forecast is made of whether this or further drilling will deliver ore grade
intersections, resources or reserves. The observed presence of spodumene within pegmatite does not necessarily equate to economic grades of lithium mineralisation until confirmed by chemical analysis which is currently underway. It is not possible to estimate the concentration of lithium in mineralisation by visual estimates and this will be determined by chemical analysis.”
To repeat, right type of rock but we're going to have to see about the lithium content.

Charger Minerals share price from ASX
Now there is optimism here. These pegmatites, this spodumene, is being found half a mile from where Core Lithium is already beginning to mine the same mineral. So there's good reason to think that there will be something there. But it is only good reason, by no means is it proof.
Our own thoughts here are simply about the larger lithium market. Quite simply, so much material is being found in so many paces that we're deeply unsure that there's going to be any scarcity value to the minerals or the metal. Yes, yes, we do know how much the car batteries of the world are going to require. But we also know - know absolutely - that there's much, much, more than that lithium out there. So those last to the party might well find out they're trying to sell into a falling market.
In fact, we would insist that this is going to be true. There will be more lithium finds than there is desire for supply. This will mean that some finds will not be developed simply because they're not needed. As we say, we insist that this will be true. The uncertainty is when will this be true and which projects aren't going to get developed?



