Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Firering Strategic Minerals - we think there’s a problem with tantalum projects

The increase in lithium extraction is likely to lead to gross oversupply of tantalum

Update : 22 Jun 2023, 04:06 PM

Firering Strategic Minerals (LON: FRG) has, to us, a basic problem. Which is that it describes its project in Cote ‘d'Ivoire as a tantalum and lithium project. It's possible to view this as just a naming, even a PR, problem, but it does give an opportunity to explain something very important about the minor metals world. The point here being that the tantalum market is about to crash.

A useful, but not complete, definition of a minor metal is one that is co-produced. One that is not mined for directly, but which is a byproduct of mining for something else. No one ever goes mining for hafnium, it's always a byproduct of zirconium processing. There are grey areas, some gold is byproduct material from copper mining for example, some is mined directly. This can become important when we consider Jervois and cobalt. So much Co is co-produced with copper and nickel that a primary cobalt mine finds itself underpriced.

Firering Strategic Minerals share price from London Stock Exchange.

This is what makes this description worry us: “Atex Lithium-Tantalum Project ("Atex"), in Côte d'Ivoire.” Now, we all know that tantalum is a common byproduct of lithium mining in spodumene. In fact, the world's largest tantalum mine used to be Greenbushes, when it was run by Sons of Gwalia. Lithium back then was the byproduct even as Greenbushes now is run as a primary lithium mine with tantalum as the byproduct.

But now think what's happening out there. Everyone and their Granny is off digging up spodumene for the lithium content. Some at least are also co-producing tantalum. But the tantalum market hasn't changed in size even as the lithium one has. The effect of this is obviously going to be to depress the tantalum price. 

This isn't something we can speculate upon, go short on. There's no tantalum future or option arrangement. There are no primary tantalum miners we can short (the only primary Ta miners are in fact those artisanal mines in central Africa). The processors, who might do well out of this, are all privately held. There's no way of speculating on tantalum other than holding physical product - which is obviously enough not a good way to try to short it.

Well, OK, we know that Ta price is going to decline and we can't bet on it doing so, Boo Hoo, eh? 

Ah, but we've still got all these people working up mines to produce both tantalum and lithium. And those forecasts of possible tantalum revenues are, we think, going to prove very overstated. 

It's entirely true that we're bears on the long term of the lithium market too. But we're just really wary of anyone, like Firering, stating that they're going after tantalum at present. Simply because so many are going after lithium.

Top Brokers