Cyxtera (NASDAQ: CYXT) stock is up 126% this morning. This isn't what we'd expect from a company in Chapter 11. Or, to be more cynical, perhaps we would expect exactly that these days. For there are people out there who will speculate on absolutely everything and with a stock price up 126% this morning who can blame them? However, it is necessary sometimes to be the responsible adult in the room which is what we're going to attempt here.
OK, sure, so some stocks are going to have speculative runs now and again. Being on the right side of them is both fun and profitable. But to stay on that right side it's necessary to work out what there's a run on the stock. In either direction, either up or down. Just noting that a price is moving isn't enough because that doesn't tell us when it's going to stop moving, or possibly even reverse.
Now we can think of why Cyxtera might move. Hey, it's a big company, $200 million per quarter revenue million per quarter revenue. Market cap is only $14 million or so. Perhaps there's some value to be retrieved here? And we've no doubt that there is some value in there. Somewhere. But a stock price is determined by how much of that value will flow to stockholders and here the answer is almost certainly none.

Cyxtera stock price from NASDAQ
The reason that the equity's not going to gain any of that value is because CYXT is in Chapter 11. That's a form of bankruptcy. Which is pretty much the definition of the equity being worth nothing. The base problem is, over and above simply not making profit, that the company is drawing in debt. The result of Chapter 11 is going to be, at best, that the creditors end up owning the equity.
And that really is it. Yes, we know that Hertz turned out differently. But there there was an asset that reversed, entirely, in value. It was the way that second hand cars rose in value during lockdown that did it. Now, to achieve a similar result with Cyxtera will require that there be some similar asset which can reverse in value. There isn't. Therefore the CYXT Chapter 11 will not turn out like the Hertz one.
The end result here being that Cyxtera might be a lovely thing to speculate in on a very short term basis but other than that it's a dud.



