Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Ulta Beauty down 13% - maybe shoplifting should still be a crime?

True, stock prices dropping does reduce inequality but perhaps this is the wrong way to do it

Update : 29 May 2023, 03:02 PM

Ulta Beauty (NASDAQ: ULTA) shares are down 13% and they've pulled down with them the stocks of other companies selling medium value fast moving consumer goods. Not, particularly, because the FMCG business is now facing lower demand but because that demand seems to be being met by people not paying for their FMCG goods. Ulta quite specifically points to: “During the earnings presentation, Ulta spoke to macro pressures as well as retail theft issues impacting not only its stores, but the broader beauty retail industry. Management noted that organized thefts are an “increasingly concerning challenge” for retailers in the space.”

Shrinkage, as it is known in the industry, has always been there. 1 to 2% is considered a pretty normal level, it's just one of those things that can never be entirely expunged. It's also known that while people do shoplift - take goods without paying for them - the major part of shrinkage comes from internal staff issues. Well, just one of those costs that retailers have to deal with. There they are with millions of dollars of goods just sitting on the shelves and some of it is going to go walkabout. Sure, store detectives and all that, but there always be some going missing.

Ulta Beauty stock price from NASDAQ

But here's the other thing. As this NowThisNews video shows that organised shoplifting is becoming a bigger issue. And beauty products - relatively small, relatively high value - are a prime target for the gangs. This is now a big enough issue that retailers are simply closing stores in certain areas - San Francisco and Portland come to mind. The margins in retail - the retail part that is, not the entire production chain - tends to run at 2 to 4%. So it doesn't ake much of a rise in shrinkage to entirely wipe out the margins at a store. When there's no profit then why be there? 

But we've also got - as in that NowThis video - those claiming that this is all about inequality. And of course we shouldn't prosecute or jail those merely claiming what is rightfully theirs. Which is why shoplifting up to near a $1,000 is now a misdemeanour, not a felony any more, in California. That is, we've got politics in the way of Ulta Beauty, or anyone else, being able to do much about this theft from the stores.

At which point there's no real surprise at both ULTA and the sector stocks moving down. We all know what the solution is - catch and prosecute shoplifters in order to reduce the incidence of shoplifting. But the prosecution, the political, system won't allow that. So, what can, in fact, be done? Other than corporations continue to lose stock and stockholders continue to lose money?

Top Brokers