Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

IDP Education drops 16% on losing its Canadian monopoly

The problem with living off politics is that politics can change

Update : 29 May 2023, 02:56 PM

IDP Education (ASX: IEL) (OTCPK: IDPUF) shares are down 16% today on the news that Canada is changing the rules about how overseas students can gain their visas to study there. This might seem like a fairly trivial change and not one that should wipe a $billion or whatever off the value of an Australian company. But this is what has happened and it's an interesting example of a difficulty with being a politics based business. IDP Education makes good money off processing visa applications - OK, that's definitely politics right there. But if politics decides that visa applications should be processed in a different manner then clearly IDP's business prospects change. Which is indeed what has just happened.

The basics of the business are that there's a huge hunger to study in the universities of the English speaking world - Australia, Ireland, UK, US, NZ and Canada. Just given the preponderance of the English language this is going to be so. However, none of those countries run an open door policy for migrants. So, there's an amount of paperwork necessary to get the student visas and documents to be able to go study in universities in those countries. This is what IDP does. Manages the tests, work processes and so on to enable students to gain their visas to go and study. Which is fine, obviously, and can be very profitable indeed.

IDP Education share price from ASX

Except here cometh the problem. What government gives government can take away again. Which is exactly what the government of Canada has just done: “IDP Education sank 15.9 per cent to $$21.71 following Canada's decision to allow competitors to enter the Student-Direct-Stream (SDS) component of student visas.” The problem is not so much that competitors will take some part of the market. Well, maybe, that might be some part of it. The larger portion is that with competition there is price pressure. Monopolists do tend to have juicy and thick profit margins - non-monopolists don't. So it's not that the new entrants are going to reduce the volume of business, it's that even the idea of new entrants even trying is going to reduce the profit that IPD can make.

It's not just the visas part either. That might well be a part of the business that can be protected. IDP also works on English language testing. And there are plenty of extant competitors who can enter the market there. There are still areas of expansion for IDP but this insistence from Canada that they face actual and real competition is most unwelcome. As the ILE share price shows.

Top Brokers