Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Churchill Downs, CHDN, drops 50% at the open - do not be alarmed

CHDN stock is suffering from a problem of success, not failure, as it falls by half at the open on Monday

Update : 22 May 2023, 12:23 PM

Churchill Downs (NASDAQ: CHDN) stock will open 50% down today. This could be taken as the result of some disaster but it's actually a sign of success. The Churchill Downs stock was simply, in the eyes of the management, becoming too expensive. So, they decided to split each share into two - thus each share will be worth half what it was but everyone will now have the two not the one. It's a purely nominal price change that is, not a real one. 

There's an interesting little note to be made about how stock market systems don't, necessarily, deal entirely well with such changes. Here's the Friday price:

Churchill Downs stock price from NASDAQ

That's the actual, pre-split price it was trading at, just under $300.


 CHDN stock price from NASDAQ

But when we move out to the month view the price is being quoted post-split. The historical prices usually are altered to reflect the effects of splits (and consolidations) but it's not necessarily true that all of the system gets updated at the same time.

As to why this is done it's an effect of that human failing, the number illusion. We humans have, in our pretty little heads, ideas about what prices “should be”. This applies to stock prices as much as to anything else. If and when stock prices get out of the range we think is “right” then we begin to think of them as “expensive” or indeed too cheap to be worth worrying with when they slip into the pennies. 

That this is just a human foible, not something objectively real, is shown by the fact that these ideas of the right price range change across different stock markets. London tends to think that £1 to £10 is about the right range for a serious company. New York tends to think $10 to $100 is. No particular reason for either range, that's just what the cultural expectation in each place is. This also explains why the New York ADR of a London listed stock tends to be 10 pieces of the London stock - it's possible to be in that sweet range in both markets that way.

Churchill Downs has been doing very well out of the Kentucky Derby. Well, not so much that as out of running the horse race betting industry for much of the US on the back of that start and brand name. So, the stock price has risen to above what the company directors think is that sensible nominal price range. Change the number of shares - a 2 for 1 split - and gain a more reasonable nominal price.  

If all of those entirely reasonable surmises about human behaviour - that number illusion - are correct then we might actually see a rise in the real price of CHDN stock this morning. But the 50% price fall is purely nominal.

Top Brokers