5E Advanced Materials (ASX: 5EA) (NASDAQ: FEAM) has an interesting plan, to co-extract lithium and boron. Nothing wrong with that at all as a plan. The world uses and needs boric acid, we've all heard endless tales of how the world is going to need more lithium as well. We can read the details of the plan here. Very good sense that plan makes too - at least as presented. But we've got to recall that such investor presentations are an attempt to sell the project to us. To convince us to buy the stock because the idea is so lovely and going to be so, so profitable. We should read such plans with a jaundiced eye therefore.
It's also true that on the release of this version of the plan 5EA has dropped 22%. Which isn't doing a great job of convincing now, is it? In fact, 5 EA Advanced shares have been falling for most of the past year. We've a near 90% value destruction in fact, from a peak near $4 to the current around 40 cents (both AUD). This is not exactly Happy Dance time for investors. So, why?

5EA Advanced Materials share price from ASX
The real problem here is that the determinant of a commodity play success is not what the company does - it's what every other company does. This is because commodity producers are price takes - that's built into the definition of what a commodity is. So, the market price will depend upon demand, yes, but also how many other suppliers enter the marketplace. That is, no commodity producer is the determiner of their own sales prices - it's everyone else in the market that defines that.
Is the world going to use more boron? Quite likely yes - therefore there's space for more boron production at a reasonable price. But now we come to one of those little details. Co-extracting boron and lithium is interesting, sure it is. But it's also not unique. And what else do we know about the world today? That there are literally hundreds of people out there trying to extract lithium. Sure, that means the lithium price is coming down off its highs - 50% down in the past 7 months or so. But there's more to it than that. Co-extraction of boron and lithium isn't unique, as we've said. So, there's more competition coming in the boron market as well. And that competition - because of co-extraction - isn't being determined by the size of the boron market.
Now of course no one actually knows but it's possible to speculate that the lithium frenzy is going to put the boron market into oversupply. At which point we'd prefer not to be in a commodity producer focused on boron, right? Thus the weakness at 5EA. Is there really going to be space for the boron production in volume and at a profitable price?



