THG (LON: THG) - formerly The Hut Group - shares dropped 13% in London today as the company announced that it had rejected the very idea of an approach from Apollo. We're all sure that shareholders are very grateful to Matt Moulding for protecting their interests this well. At which point the consistent critique from some in The City, that Moulding just isn't the right person to be running a publicly listed company, might have a point. For this isn't the sort of thing that someone in that position is quite supposed to do.
Now, that Apollo - as many others have done recently - was trying to bottom feed is obvious enough. The THG share price is well below where it started. Something that, given losses might be reasonable. But there's also a definite feeling that THG is trading below a reasonable valuation of the business. There must, therefore, be something holding that valuation back. Which is where the City gossip comes into play.
THG share price from London Stock ExchangeThe announcement of the rejection of the Apollo - indicative only - bid is here. The offer's too low, we don't like the structure of it and so on. Pretty boilerplate stuff in fact.
But Moulding also has a LinkedIn post explaining his position. Which is, by City standards, really pretty odd.
“PE interest isn't surprising. For the 3 years before IPO, THG shares traded at £3. Having doubled in size we then listed THG at £5 a share in Sep 20. They rose to £8 in the first-year post IPO but, after the Numis led short attacks when they weren't made a Broker to THG, shares fell to as low as 30p in late 2022.”
He's accusing a merchant bank (“investment bank” to Americans) of deliberately shorting the shares - in order to crash their value - because they weren't appointed advisors to the company? It's not just that that's the sort of thing that The City won't like it's that many in The City will think he's either ignorant or mad to even suggest such a thing. But then Moulding has, for some years now, been regarded as someone who doesn't quite get how public equity markets really work.
At which point we might have found our reason as to why THG is undervalued.



