Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Icahn Enterprises, IEP, drops 15% - this shows the value of short sellers

That Icahn Enterprises has dropped 35% since the Hindenburg short selling report isn’t the point, not at all

Update : 11 May 2023, 12:38 PM

Icahn Enterprises (NASDAQ: IEP) stock is down 35% since the publication of that Hindenburg short selling report into the company. It's possible to think of this as being merely the destruction of value by someone telling tales. That's the usual reaction of most corporate managements to most short selling reports. It's even possible that that's the correct reaction to some of them - it's easy enough to cobble something together that will hit an already fragile stock price after all. 

On the other hand short sellers can - and we don't claim either way over Hindenburg, either this report or any other - do the world a favour by uncovering corporate malfeasance or even just overly aggressive accounting practices. If someone had done this to Polly Peck all those years ago - the information was right there in the accounts after all - then many private investors would have been left much better, not worse, off. 

So, it's possible to run either side of the short argument. Those making such bets, publishing reports about companies like Icahn, can be seen as useful toilers in the mines of capitalism or those undermining the whole process. Your, or our, choice.


Icahn Enterprises stock price from NASDAQ

This latest decline in the IEP stock price is more instructive though. For it comes as a result of the announcement that the SEC is now looking into the accounting at Icahn. At which point we could wonder why we need short sellers when the authorities can - and do - look into these thoughts of bad accounting.

Except that's the wrong way to read this and it's the wrong way for this reason: “Carl Icahn's company disclosed in a regulatory filing on Wednesday that it received the request from prosecutors on May 3, the day after short seller Hindenburg Research released a report saying it believed Icahn Enterprises was overvalued and held some of its assets at an inflated worth.” The SEC swung into action the day after Hindenburg published. That is, the short seller is that canary in that coalmine of capitalism, the warning or the trigger. 

Which accords with our general view of the world. SEC bureaucrats get paid no more, no less, whether they investigate a corporation or not. Short sellers only get paid if they both investigate and also uncover something that moves a stock price. So, we'd expect short sellers to uncover material information better than SEC bureaucrats.

And that, right there, is the value of short sellers. They're motivated in a way the authorities are not - after all, incentives matter.

Top Brokers