ASOS (LON: ASC) shares are down another 11% today on the back of the release of their results. As expected - but worse than had been expected - sales are down, margins are down and profits have disappeared into being losses.

ASOS results from ASOS
The result of this being:

ASOS share price from London Stock Exchange
Here's what the real and basic problem was and is. Of course online has been eating retail sales but it's been at about 1% of total retail sales per year each year for a couple of decades now. Then came lockdown - with a vast leap in the portion of the market which was online. As we can see here at the ONS.
The mistake was then made of thinking that this jump was a permanent and higher level of online sales as a portion of the total market. But look at that ONS chart again - that's not the way it worked out. Online as a percentage of retail fell back to where it would have been on the trend growth.
The problem is that both sets of us made that same mistake. The online retailers assumed it was a permanent change and so rightsized stock levels and delivery tech for the higher level of business. That of course caused large losses when the tide receded. We out here as investors also applied higher growth valuations to the equities - something that has also reversed as the tide receded.
ASOS, like other online retailers, is a sensible enough business and as long as it rightsizes its cost base could and should do well. But from a lower level than we thought it would only two years back. And given that growth will be slower the revenue multiple to be applied to it is also lower.
It's always vital to differentiate between cyclical changes and structural ones - valuations of online retailers in the UK got well ahead of themselves by making the mistake of not grasping which type of change was happening during lockdown.



