Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

MTM Critical Metals up 15% - name changes like this worry us

Which minerals a company should explore for changes as with fashions. So name changes can be a guide to what’s in fashion

Update : 08 May 2023, 01:17 PM

MTM Critical Metals (ASX: MTM) is up another 15% today on the back of the rights issue and name change. What used to be Mt Monger Resources is now MTM Critical Metals. There's also been a rights issue which has replenished the fiscal tanks of the company to the tune of $2.8 million or so. It's possible to see a number of positives in this. For an exploration company to have refinanced might well mean that past shareholders haven't done well but for us thinking of buying in now there's the knowledge that they are financed. 

On the other hand we might think a little less of MTM given that the management has reduced its stake as a result of the rights issue. We'd prefer to see stakes being maintained. On the other hand of course there's no point in coming to market if the capital base must be sustained by the management itself - the entire point of a capital market is that outside capital becomes available, over and above what the management and current owners can provide. So it becomes a bit of a mixed bag - more capital is good, but lower management exposure isn't so good.  

MTM Critical Metals share price from ASX

However, the bigger issue that worries us. Of course there are fashions in investing - there are fashions in everything human. So too are there fashons in what small exploration companies should go exploring for. At the grander level this is how capitalism works - prices change, people try to change what they supply in order to capture the profits from those prices. In this manner the changes in demand which changed the prices get met. It's a great and grand system overall.

But like every fashion it's also possible to be a bit late to the party. MTM has moved from gold prospecting to rare earths and other critical metals (niobium, for example). Thus the name change. And we tend to think those parties are over. We know of several new niobium mines ready to roll. We know of at least 7 rare earths announcements on the ASX alone just in the past 6 weeks. By definition those are all projects which are a year or three in advance of where MTM is. We don't know how long this boom is going to last, obviously, but we do think that gearing up to explore for “critical minerals” today is a bit like turning up in bell bottoms and a tank top to a Sex Pistols launch party in 1976. Just sufficiently behind the curve to be unlikely to be successful.

Top Brokers