Western Alliance Bancorporation (NYSE: WAL) stock dropped 22% after hours Wednesday night on the back of a rapport meant to reassure everyone about the bank's stability. And looking at the numbers in the release it should reassure everyone. The fragilities that afflicted Silicon Valley and then First Republic banks just don't seem to be there. Which should indeed provide reassurance to all invested in bank equity. As well as keep the Fed, FDIC and the rest happy too. But despite the numbers looking good that doesn't seem to have provided all that much reassurance.
Recall what the specific problem at the earlier bank failures was. There are losses in the hold to maturity portfolio on a mark to market basis. That's fine, as long as those losses don't have to be crystalised. The only time those positions would have to be sold is if there is a bank run - the deposits flee. If uninsured depositors get worried then they might flee, that triggers the sale of the HtM portfolio, the losses wipe out the bank. While that's not wholly and exactly accurate it's a pretty good guide to what was happening.
So, if Western Alliance can show that it's not losing deposits, most of its deposit base is insured - especially the larger relationships - and it also has sufficient liquidity to be able to cover the loss of such deposits without having to liquidate underwater positions then - well, then it's fine, isn't it?

Western Alliance stock price from NYSE
The details of the announcement are here. As we can see from the reaction of the stock price the market didn't find this to be wholly reassuring. One reason is that bank runs - which is what we call those deposits fleeing - are not wholly rational. They're much more like the herd panic that can afflict groups at times. There's an element of people playing Frank Drebben in trying to stop such events - nothing to see here, move along now, doesn't quite work. That everything looks fine should work but what if it doesn't?
The other reason is that if people do have to reassure then, well, how reassuring is that?
The investor problem here is that currently regional banks stocks are not behaving entirely rationally. Therefore rational thought isn't a good guide as to what's going to happen.



