Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

The Top Financial, mania seems to have happened and gone already then

It’s difficult to be absolutely certain but the TOPs stock price seems to have, umm, topped out

Update : 01 May 2023, 11:48 AM

Top Financial (NASDAQ: TOP) went absolutely wild lsat week. As we said about TOP, and again about Top Financial and other Chinese low float financials, there was no particular or specific reason for this. Well, that's other than it was a small cap, low float - with a large short position in that free float - stock that by its very nature would be subject to significant price volatility if there was a change in demand. Trade was high, many multiples of normal daily volume. But it wouldn't have taken much at the beginning to have started the stampede.

And once one small cap Chinese financial stock started to go wild then the others were pretty much sure to follow. Thus as we noted movement in MEGL and even the AMTD Twins juddered a bit. The point here is that there just wasn't anything sensible to change valuations. No news, not even anything that could be used as news. Just a change in price which then led others to believe that a further price change could happen and their buying on that basis is actually what then changed that price. A stampede that is - or as we can also put it, a mania. 

The thing about manias being that they do end.

Here's TOP on the way up:

Top Financial from NASDAQ

Here's TOP on Friday including postmarket:

Top Financial from NASDAQ 

On the assumption that that is all just crowd behaviour then we'd all probably assume that the fun and games have already happened. It's also true that there's absolutely nothing that could even indicate that TOP is worth $2 billion or so. Revenue - yes revenue, not profit - is some $5 million and while that was growth of 60% and more in the last financials that's still not a justification of that sort of valuation.

No, there are no secrets in the company. It is not trading itself, it is not a principal. It is not trading against its clients - like a bookmaker - and so has not made some vast profit by reading the market right. It's a futures broker, it lives off the set fees for handling the paperwork of futures trading. And that's it. The only way for the business to grow is to process more trades. While it's doing that effectively, so far as we know, there just isn't going to be the sort of growth that will support a $billions valuation.  

Sure, Top Financial was exciting. But that's all it was, one of those little manias that grip markets from time to time. It's even true that having a little bet on it all would have been exciting - but don't, whatever you do, confuse that, in any sense, with investing.

Top Brokers