Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

CityDev down 6% on results - good but not good enough perhaps

CityDev released results yesterday, the stock opened well down this morning. Perhaps European commercial property just isn’t quite the in thing today?

Update : 27 Apr 2023, 05:24 PM

CityDev (SGX: CTDM) stock is down near 6% Thursday morning. This is off the back of their results announcement on Wednesday - the stock opened down and kept going. There was nothing wrong in those announced results, no particular gremlins that were hidden away or anything. However, as often happens, results time is when people think through the proposition more fully. And perhaps European commercial property just isn't where people want to be these days? 

As we say, the results themselves aren't bad. We'd quibble a bit with a 3%-ish rise in the rent roll as being a good performance in a time of 10% inflation especially since there is a claim of CPI indexation on those rents. But then no company does report inflation adjusted accounts - however much we'd like them to. The portfolio is concentrated in Germany, France and Spain and that's where we think some of the discomfort might be. For we've the example of the British property market before us and that's not looking good at all. Yes, the Continent often is out of step with Britain (as the British would put it, it's them out of step with us being a common enough British idea) but that then brings the question of whether this is all cyclical or whether there's a structural change going on? 


CityDev stock price from SGX

As we've seen in Britain the retail commercial property market has been very hard hit by the rise of internet shopping. 10 and 12% of all retail space is empty as online eats retail spending at perhaps 1 percentage point of retail sales per year. That was accelerated by lockdown and has fallen back to trend again. Office commercial property is also suffering from lockdown. Work from Home was tried out on a large scale for the first time and many are finding that large, city central, offices simply are no longer required.

We agree, the different - and especially British - commercial property markets work to different cycles. But structural problems are likely to surface in each of them. And that's really what the CityDev issue is. How badly are those Continental markets going to be hit by the same structural problems that have made a complete mess of the British commercial property sector? That's what the bet is and results time seems to have concentrated attention upon this.  

Top Brokers