Jervois Global (ASX: JRV) recently slumped as it became obvious that the Idaho cobalt project simply was not going to work. The more cobalt they mined there the more money they would lose. That's simply because the global cobalt price is below the costs of hard rock mining of cobalt. Nothing anyone can really do about that. Obviously, this is a pity, as the Idaho thing is ready to roll. But this is also something that happens - miners are commodity producers and thus price takers.
So, one view of the Jervois prospects is as a leveraged and long out of the money option on the global cobalt price. If there's a large and sustained rise then perhaps there's value there. There are other smaller operations within the corporate shell but compared to that US project they're of trivial importance. That's also a bet that we'd not want to take - we're minded to think that the cobalt price drop is more than just cyclical, we think it's close to being structural.
The problem here is that most cobalt is produced as a byproduct (from nickel or copper production). Folk don't start or stop Ni or Cu mining on the basis of the Co price. So it's entirely possible for the cobalt industry to keep producing, for years or even decades, at less than the all-in cost of cobalt production. That's just a feature of the byproduct metals marketplace. Note possible, not will there. But a stand alone cobalt mine must cover its all-in costs from cobalt alone. This being another feature of byproduct metal markets, you don;t want to be a primary producer when the price slumps.

Jervois Global share price from ASX
We have to admit to a certain prejudice here too. We're long enough in the tooth that we recall an earlier incarnation of Jervois that was going to mine nickel laterites. Except not for the Ni and Co contents, they were going to produce scandium. The problem there being that an economic size of mine and or plant meant producing several times global consumption of scandium each year. Unsurprisingly, that didn't in fact get financed. It's most unkind of us to see the parallel here - lots of work done with the end result being an uneconomic project that doesn't go ahead. But that is the way that it can be seen here at Jervois.



