Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Homestreet, HMST, sinks 35% - the next banking domino to fall?

Homestreet falls 35% on recent results - but the big problem is will HMST suffer a deposits outflow?

Update : 26 Apr 2023, 01:12 PM

Homestreet (NASDAQ: HMST) should worry us all in one sense and in another shouldn't worry us at all. That depends upon whether we want to look at this from the point of view of holding HMST stock or at the higher level of the overall banking system or economy. Homestreet is the holding company for Homestreet Bank which is primarily a commercial and mortgage lending bank in the Western US. A perfectly respectable business to be in and one that in normal times we'd evaluate purely on management performance. These are not normal times for banking stocks.

We had the results for Homestreet and they weren't good. EPS of $0.27 was a miss by $0.13, the revenue miss was around 5%, $3 million or so on roughly $60 million. OK, so that's not good, we'd market down a stock for that, surely. But not by 35%. So there's something else going on here as well, obviously. The problem is, equally obviously, what is happening at First Republic Bank. What happens if depositors start to lose confidence? 

Homesteet stock price from NASDAQ

Well, actually, what would happen at Homestreet is rather simple and obvious. If that deposit base decides to run then we'll have a bank run - obviously, this is what it means. But will we then have the attempt to save it? The agonising we had over Silicon Valley, or are having over First Republic? No, no, we wouldn't.

There would be the usual FHLB support available, the Fed itself might offer extra liquidity. The FDIC would be monitoring and so on. But if a run started then there would be none of the extraordinary measures. For Homestreet just isn't that important. With a market capitalisation of some $330 million or so everyone would agree that HMST could go bust, be managed efficiently in run off and, well, we know how to deal with small banks going under. We've got the system to deal with it too. The stockholders lose everything, the depositors are made whole by selling off the loan book and that's that. 

No, we are not saying this is going to happen. But we are pointing out that it's only the major regional banks who are going to gain extraordinary measures. Any of the smaller banks that get into trouble will be allowed to fail - a managed failure, to be sure, but still Pop! And they're gone as far as the equity is concerned.

Top Brokers