China Natural Resources (NASDAQ: CHNR) looks rather cruelly treated here. They have bought a lithium mine in Zimbabwe for what looks like a reasonable enough price and they have gained a pretty good financing deal on it too. Do not forget, CHNR is a $14 million capitalization and they have got a $120 million deal. One that they can actually finance too, as most payments come in the future. So, why is the stock price down 11% on Friday? Allow us to introduce you to the concept of tunnelling.
OK, so Zimbabwean lithium assets aren't the most valuable, as the country insists upon local processing of material. Given energy constraints in that country this does make things more expensive - and thus the original assets less valuable - than they could be. It's also true that the lithium price is falling strongly and has been for 6 months now. This might not be quite the time to be buying lithium assets if that output price is going to continue to fall. But some sort of risk must be taken and otherwise the deal looks pretty good. So why the thumbs down from the market?

China Natural Resources share price from NASDAQ
The little difficulty here is who CHNR bought that mine from: “China Natural Resources Inc said on Tuesday it would acquire Williams Minerals, the operator of a lithium mine in Zimbabwe, amid surging demand for the metal used in batteries for electric vehicles.”
Well, OK. But: “Feishang also holds a controlling stake in China Natural Resources.”
This is a shuffling of resources within the Feishang ownership chain. Which might - might we insist all understand - be known as tunnelling. Moving assets which are owned within China into a corporate body which might still ultimately be opened inside China but has an extra layer of legal separation from China.
Thus the modest reaction to the deal itself. Not a great deal changes that is, Feishang still controls the same asset. One of those things that the rest of us probably should not bother much with. It is even possible to go negative on it. The loan notes etc which China Natural is using might mean cash flowing from us into China rather than us benefitting from the purchase, After all, it is possible that lithium assets are at the peak of their value right now, this is a time to be selling them, not buying.



