iEnergizer (LON: IBPO) shares dropped 80% Friday morning in London on the announcement that the company is to cancel its listing on AIM, the junior part of the London market. IBPO is 82% owned by EICR of Cyprus so there's not much of a free flat there to start with. Liquidity in the shares is not high as a result of that. But, with a £500 million market capitalization there is still reasonable such liquidity. On the other hand the company thinks that the listing doesn't aid in any access to capital so why bother to be listed at all?
There are costs to a listing, as they point out. Having to meet all the rules (slavery statement, ESG statements, all that malarkey) imposes costs, sure it does. If you are not going to try to raise capital, a listing does not aid in raising capital anyway, then why carry those costs? Which is the conclusion they have come to - let's cancel the IBPO listing.
iEnergiser share price from London Stock ExchangeOh well is one possible response. Another is to think about this for a moment. There will still be the matched bargain facility but clearly that has much less liquidity. So, that 80% price drop is purely a result of that loss of liquidity. Shareholders will now find it more difficult to move in or out of a position in iEnergizer.
What this tells us that those in favour of a financial transactions tax (the Tobin Tax) are talking nonsense. Because the entire idea of that is to reduce liquidity. You know, there is too much gambling and the world would be a better place with less trading of pieces of paper. But if less liquidity leads to an 80% fall in a share price. Well, that means that investing when there's less liquidity will reduce returns. Which, in turn, means that less investment will be done. That is, taxing liquidity leads to less investment - a poorer future society.
Those holding iEnergizer stock right now may or may not be comforted by this lesson. But we've got, right here, a real world example of why an FTT is a really, really bad idea. Which is useful as it can - and will be - used as an argument against those proposing such financial transactions taxes.



