Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Why National CineMedia, NCMI, is up 153% on bankruptcy filing - weird, eh?

A normal result of a Chapter 11 filing is that equity goes to zero. This hasn’t happened at NCMI, quite the contrary it’s up 153% - why?

Update : 13 Apr 2023, 09:42 AM

National CineMedia (NASDAQ: NCMI) is, at pixel time, up 153% which is nice. It's also up that much because the major trading subsidiary has just declared Chapter 11 bankruptcy. That's not how these things normally work. Chapter 11 is usually an admission that the debt is greater than the assets therefore there's nothing left for the shareholders. So, why would the equity rise in price in Chapter 11? 

There have been special exemptions, Hertz being one we can think of. But that really was a special case. So, what is it here that leads to equity gaining money out of a Chapter 11 filing? The answer seems to be in the structure of the business itself. The little secret the way we read it being this: “And NCMI will receive an ownership interest of about 14% in the restructured NCM LLC, vs. a current 48%. (Regal parent Cineworld and Cinemark had owned the remainder of NCM LLC;” We'll come to why this is important in a moment.

We should though point out that we'd not quite appreciated the subtlety of what was happening in our earlier report in National CineMedia. Or, to reduce that to plainspeak, we were wrong. This does happen, Big Boys admit it, we're Big Boys, therefore….


National CineMedia stock price from NASDAQ

So what really happened? As best we can work this out. NCMI runs the ads in the movie houses. Or rather, the LLP which NCMI owned that part of did. That LLP got into vast debt problems - as with so many in the movie business what with lockdowns - and so was, effectively, bankrupt. So, the business belongs to the debtors. But the debtors aren't, in fact, interested in owning the business - they want to maximise their return, which is not the same thing. But the value of the LLP is maximised by having the movie house chains owning a goodly part of the company that organises the advertising in the movie houses. So, debtors of the LLP maximise their collection by keeping the movie chains in the ownership structure. Which, pretty much, means keeping NCMI in that ownership structure too. 

Basically, the debtors maximise their value by keeping Cineworld and Cinemark in the loop, which means keeping NCMI there too. And so a Chapter 11 means a rise, not fall, in the value of the equity. Because now the debt burden is gone but some portion of the equity remains. It's an oddity but that's the best explanation we've got here. 

Top Brokers