Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Tupperware down 46% on going concern problems - they might not survive this

At least the NYSE quotation for TUP, the Tupperware Brands Corporation, is under threat as they can’t get their paperwork together.

Update : 11 Apr 2023, 11:16 AM

Tupperware Brands Corporation (NYSE: TUP) is down 46% on worries over their going concern status. There's at least a serious risk that they'll lose their NYSE quotation and there's a possibility that the company will have to cease to trade. Of course, such risks face every company all the time but it's how much of a risk which is the interesting question. At some point that risk comes to all - the average final price of a stock is after all zero because everyone does go bust at some point.

The usual worry about a company that's not doing well is that the price falls below the minimum bid level - $1 - and so loses the NYSE or NASDAQ quote and falls down to the OTC. This kills value as there's less liquidity there, less ability to raise new capital and so on. This is also fairly easy to solve, conduct a reverse share split - a consolidation - and increase the nominal stock price that way. The Tupperware problem is different from this. It's also rather more difficult to solve.

Tupperware Brands Corporation stock price from NYSE

The different problem here is that the price is still above that minimum bid. What's actually the problem here is that they've not got their paperwork sorted out. They need to file a 10K for 2022. Yes, very lawyer and accountant so they've filed an 8K to explain why the 10K is late. Which is rather worse than had been expected. It was already known why the annual report was late - they've found out that the accounts are a mess. Retained earnings (ie, the capital of the company) was over stated by perhaps $28 million before 2020. This is really pretty late to be finding that out. That they just can't file the form shows that they've got problems sorting this out. Further, in the 8K, the form they did file, there's a “going concern” warning. Now, sure, they've got 6 months to get that 10K sorted out. But it looks like sorting the accounts out to enable that is showing up other, how to put this delicately, mild little problems with accounting policies and tracking.

The real admission in the 8K is that the risks of Tupperware just going kablooie have risen. Therefore the stock price plunges, that's just how it works. Now, whether they can get it sorted out or not, well, that's the bet for any bull position here. People who lose control of the accounting system might not be the very best folk to try to put it together again. Maybe.

Top Brokers