Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Is AFC Energy making the right hydrogen bet here?

AFC Energy is working on using ammonia as the carrier for hydrogen in energy applications. This could undoubtedly work - but is it the right technological bet to be making?

Update : 24 Mar 2023, 12:40 PM

AFC Energy (LON: AFC) is up 6% on their announcement of a new ammonia cracking platform. This is one of those ideas that could undoubtedly be made to work. It's a solution to at least part of the climate change problem. That hydrogen is going to be part of that solution seems obvious as there really are areas of the economy that cannot be powered directly by renewables or even electricity. 

However, being about right with something that could work isn't enough to be able to make a profit. For that we need the new tech to actually be adopted at large scale. And that's rather more difficult to forecast - this is the base problem with AFC Energy and with near all other players in this space. Not what is a viable technology, but which of the potentially viable ones will be picked up at scale? As AFC tells us “The Hydrogen Council now predicts that investment in international hydrogen trade is forecast to grow to US$150 billion by 2030, before increasing to US$1.5 trillion by 2050.  A large percentage is forecast to be via synthetic fuels such as ammonia,”. Can't see any reason to doubt that indeed a good working assumption is that it's true. 

AFC Energy share price from

 London Stock Exchange

The problem is in the use of the phrase “such as ammonia”.

For it's entirely true that if we build out renewables - wind and solar mostly - then we can make green hydrogen in quantity. But hydrogen is very difficult to store and transport, so perhaps moving up the chemistry chain to synthetic ammonia is the solution? Could be and that's what AFC is betting upon here. Ammonia is easier than H2 to move around, it can be cracked to liberate the hydrogen (exactly what this announcement is about) to make that available to a fuel cell at the desired point and time. 

However, If we've got green hydrogen and chemistry then it's also possible to make the same old boring hydrocarbons (with CO2 sucked out of the atmosphere) that we use already. Porsche is already trialling just such a move would bail Rolls Royce out of its long term problem. That is, once we move to synthfuels - which seems like a very sensible solution - then it might well be that ammonia and fuel cells aren't in fact the correct solution.

That's what the AFC Energy problem is - the technology probably will work, but so will several others so which of the several is it that will become mass market? 

Top Brokers