ProShares Ultra Bloomberg Natural Gas (NYSEARCA: BOIL) and ProShares UltraShort Bloomberg Natural Gas (NYSEARCA: KOLD) have their uses in an investment portfolio. That use is for short term speculations on the natural gas price. By short term we do mean intraday, possibly overnight if you really must. The reason is that these are leveraged ETFs and that's just the way ETFs work out. Leveraged versions of them will lose you money if you hold them over time.
BOIL and KOLD are mirror images of each other. One is bull, the other bear, they track the Bloomberg natural gas index. That in itself is a little problematic as that's a US index, the global gas price varies dramatically. But, still, if a speculation - or a hedge - on the natural gas price is required then why not? But, and really very important, only for the short term.
The reason why can be seen here:

BOIL stock price from NASDAQ

KOLD stock price NASDAQ
OK, we can see that those are mirrors of each other. That performance throughout the day they are the inverse of each other. That's great.
But longer term?

BOIL stock price from NASDAQ

KOLD stock price from NASDAQ
Well, that looks sorta the same, sorta the same shape at least. And natural gas prices have been falling over this past 6 months, we know that. So, the Bull should have been losing money, the Bear making it.
But now think a little bit. The loss on the bull is from $40 (about) to $2. The gain on the bull is $20 (about) to $80. Those are no longer symmetrical. Or, to use a slightly different timescale, YTD on BOIL is minus 85%, gain on KOLD is 199%. Now, if those returns were to be mirror of each other and KOLD was up 200% then BOIL should be down only 50%. Or, if BOIL is down 85% then KOLD should be up 600% (if we've got our math right, not a certainty).
One is bull, the other is bear, they should mirror each other - except they're leveraged ETFs. And that's what the cost of gaining access to the leverage is. That over time the resets, the costs of constructing the ETF, are so high that a long term position is guaranteed to lose you money. The loss is that difference in the performance either way.
The lesson here is that it's absolutely fine to use leveraged ETFs for what they are designed for - short term speculative hedges or speculations. Short term here being today, maybe, possibly, including tomorrow. Holding these things for the long term is a guaranteed way to lose money - so, don't do it. Long term, leverage, ETF, just not a mixture that should ever appear in your plans.



