Health Minister Mohammad Nasim yesterday told parliament that Bangladesh was the only country in the world where physicians provided treatment even on holidays – a statement health experts have described as “untrue.”
According to parliamentary norms, telling lies or providing untrue statement is a serious offence. A minister of the legislature telling lies may even be forced to leave office in vibrant democracies.
Nasim, who after assuming office in January vowed to force truant doctors to stay in rural areas and warned of administrative actions, made the pro-doctor statement as a group of opposition lawmakers spoke against the proposed budgetary allocation of over Tk11,176 crore for the health sector in the upcoming fiscal year.
“Nowhere in the world will you find a doctor on holidays even if the patient dies. In Bangladesh, however, emergency services are available even on holidays,” Nasim said, adding that doctors in Bangladesh worked very hard.
Earlier, Jatiya Party lawmaker Mohammad Noman, Sawkat Chowdhury, Nurul Islam Milon and independent MP Rustum Ali Faraji heavily criticised doctors.
“The health sector is in a fragile state...Dhaka Medical College Hospital is the largest slum. Doctors and nurses have been busy with health business,” Noman said, opposing the proposed budgetary allocation.
“You can sense the smell of graves in hospitals. Doctors posted at upazilas go to their workplaces once a week to sign the attendance book and practise privately in towns and cities,” he said.
Noman said dishonest hospital staff intentionally damage machines and sell medicines in the market.
Nurul Islam alleged that doctors were not interested in serving rural people. He suggested that students enrolling in the MBBS course should compulsorily live in villages for two months when they begin school. They should again return to village for a stipulated time to develop empathy for the poor rural people.
He also proposed allocating the ministry only Tk1.
Refuting the allegations, Nasim said it was not the duty of the health minister or the premier to ensure doctors’ presence at grassroots level.
Terming the Mps’ allegations illogical, he said: “As representatives of the local people, you have the responsibilities to monitor whether doctors attend workplaces.”
Experts criticised Nasim for his “untrue” statement.
“This [what Nasim said in parliament] is totally wrong,” Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury, the trusty of Gonoshasthya Kendra, told the Dhaka Tribune last night.
He said doctors for emergency services remained available everywhere in the world, including the US, the UK, Canada, Australia and New Zealand.
“General practitioners are available round the clock, including on all religious and national days and even during Christmas holidays,” said Zafrullah, adding: “If situation demands, they even hire temporary doctors. They never leave any patient unattended.”
He said doctors would be forced to stay in villages if the government wanted.
Professor Dr Rashide Mahbub, former president of Bangladesh Medical Association, told the Dhaka Tribune: “I do not know what circumstances made the minister make such a statement. There is no country in the world where a government and a civil society exist but doctors are unavailable.
“In developed countries, doctors can do private practice on holidays but they cannot entirely remain absent from public hospitals.”
Dr Rashide, however, said Nasim’s claim was “partially correct” for healthcare specialists. “They may remain absent on holidays in developed countries,” he said.



