Mobile courts across the country including the capital have been frequently destroying fruits contaminated with formalin. However, a group of experts and professionals argue that the way of checking fruits does not conform to scientific standards, and that the method is wrong.
They say although the drives to prevent formalin-mixed fruits from reaching the consumer is praiseworthy, the “faulty” method is contributing to more wastage of food products and possibly subjecting many innocent vendors to fines and prison terms.
Chemists, biochemists and chemical engineers at a press conference yesterday termed the formalin-testing method with Formaldehyde Meter Z-300 “wrong.”
The event organised by Bangladesh Fresh Fruits Consumers’ Association (BFFCA), an awareness building organisation to ensure sound public health, at the National Press Club was chaired by Dr Abdul Wadud.
Dhaka University’s biochemistry teacher Prof Ishtiaq Mahmud and Prof Nilufa Nahar of chemistry, and Buet’s chemical engineering department teacher Prof Dr Mohidus Samad Khan also spoke at the press conference.
Prof Ishtiaq said: “The ongoing drive against formalin is not based on scientific standards. The method is not acceptable because the device is not capable of reading properly the amount of formalin present in fruits.
“I am surprised with the government decision and also concerned over the panic among people over the presence of formalin in food.”
Prof Ishtiaq suggested that the government stop the frequent “unethical drives” and take initiative to find out the adulteration sources. He demanded tracing the persons responsible for mixing formalin, carbide and others toxic chemical in fruits and other food items, and bringing them to book.
Prof Nilufa said: “All traders do not use formalin in fruits, but the mobile courts have been destroying huge amounts of fruit based on the faulty results shown on Formaldehyde Meter Z-300. This tool is incompatible for the task and not acceptable.”
Answering a question, she said there was no specific machine in the market for testing formalin limits in fruits.
“Only sample test in laboratories is the only appropriate and acceptable process to assess the existence of formalin in food items,” she added.
On June 11, the DMP launched a drastic anti-formalin drive in the capital, armed with Formaldehyde Meter Z-300, and has so far seized and destroyed a huge amount of contaminated fruits after assessment.
However, the electronic device is meant for testing the concentration level of formaldehyde in the air.
According to agriculturalists and several research institutes in the country including the Institute of Food Science and Technology (IFST) and the Bangladesh Agricultural Research Council, the Formaldehyde Meter Z-300 is an instrument to measure concentration of chemicals or gases in the air, not in food items.
Even it is not used on food items in the US where it was manufactured.
The manufacturer, Environmental Sensors Company, defines the device as a hand-held instrument to measure formaldehyde concentration within a range of 0-30ppm (parts per million) and a resolution of 0.01ppm.
Prof Mohidus Samad said: “We do not want anybody to use formalin in food but we also do not want to see anyone subjected to punishment without getting confirmation. It is not untrue that the ongoing drive against formalin is not based on scientific standards.
“The government should stop the drive and take steps towards laboratory tests. The sources of contamination should be traced with the help of detectives.”
BFFCA Convener Abdul Wadud blamed corrupt bureaucrats and some multi-national juice companies for inspiring the drive for their financial benefits.
“The corrupt government servants have taken bribes from a company, which is marketing the Formaldehyde Meter Z-300 in our country. The original price of this device is only around Tk10,000, but the company is charging Tk1.2-1.5 lakh,” he said.
Wadud also urged the government to stop the controversial and unethical anti-formalin drive.
He also announced an eight-point demand to ensure availability of fresh foods and other daily necessities.
Meanwhile, the fruit traders both wholesalers and retailers across the country termed the drive a means of harassment and demanded that it be stopped immediately.
The Dhaka Metropolitan Fruits Import-Export and the Merchants’ Multiple Cooperative Society yesterday kept the shutters of their shops down until 2pm in line with a protest programme announced earlier.
The retailers in the capital’s Badamtali market also formed a human chain on the same issue.
On Wednesday, the Dhaka Metropolitan Fruit Traders Association called an indefinite strike in the capital protesting the ongoing drive. Mango traders and growers in Chapainawabganj extended their support. The strike was called off yesterday.



