The book building method – an IPO price discovery method of stocks – has been resumed in a new shape after more than two years.
Amid wide criticism from every corner for its flaws, the securities regulator in January 2011 temporarily suspended the method that was largely blamed for the market debacle in late 2010 and later in September 2011 modified it taking views and opinions from stakeholders.
Since then the method has been struggling to take off, but recently some companies were preparing to go public using the method, sources said.
Bangladesh Securities and Exchange Commission (BSEC) has allowed United Power Generation and Distribution this month to commence bidding by the eligible institutional investors for price discovery of issuance.
Some issue management companies are working to file IPO using the method to the regulator, sources in the issue management said. Some other has taken “wait and see” policy in the wake of market volatility, they said.
“As the method earned some bad name earlier, many issuers feel discouraged to go public under this method,” said a head of an issue management company. “But as far as I know a very few issue management companies are handling with such IPO.”
Under the modified book building method, indicative price does not exceed 15 times of weighted average earnings per share (EPS) of the preceding three years, or three times of net asset value (NAV), or whichever is lower but not less than the NAV of a stock.
In the bidding for price discovery, at least 20 institutions from six categories will have to participate. From each category, at least three institutions will have to take part in the bidding.
Directors and sponsors of an issuer company would not be an issue manager for their own company under the system.
An issuer company will have to run advertisements in five national dailies with a 10-day notice about holding a road-show, and within next three workdays of the road-show, the issuer company must set the indicative price of its shares and submit it to the SEC.
The asset management companies would be allowed to become institutional investors and they can participate in the bidding.
Some 10% shares of an IPO will be reserved for the institutional investors who will set the indicative price, and the ratio of eligible institutional investors would be 40%. An eligible institutional investor can bid for the highest 5% share. The lock-in period for the eligible institutional investors would be four months.
“The method is still cumbersome and time consuming,” said MA Hafiz, a director of a leading issue management company AAA Consultant.
When any issuer hears the procedure of the method, he said, they prefer to go for fixed price method instead of book building method.
“Price discovery method should be simplified,” he said, adding that the market will determine the price of a company’s share in line with the book building rules.
Union Capital managing director Akter H Sannamat said the market lacks enough analysts for valuation of a company, which reflected earlier through inflating pricing.
“The pricing should be done professionally taking company’s fundamentals and present market situation into account,” he said.
Earlier, former BSEC chairman Faruq Ahmad Siddiqi said there should not be any cap or ceiling in determining the indicative price.
“Instead of identifying the basic problems and solving those, inclusion of new clauses such as the valuation ones will hamper the spirit of the book building method.”
After the stock market debacle in December 2010, the government instructed the BSEC to suspend the book building method.
But following recommendations by a probe committee on the share market crash, the government later instructed the regulator to bring changes to the book building norms, instead of suspending the system, as it is practiced in other countries.
Before the suspension of the method, there had been complains that many companies were misusing the system taking advantage of some rules of the method and in connivance with the regulator, auditors and issue managers inflated indicative prices, which do not match with their fundamentals.
In some cases, some auditors helped the company authorities in fixing high indicative prices through window-dressed balance sheets.
As a result, a vast amount of money was allegedly siphoned off from the stock market causing liquidity crisis.



