Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Stock refinance scheme – A steroid perhaps

Update : 27 Jan 2014, 06:23 PM

The stock refinancing fund of Tk9bn may not be doing much to solve the existing problems in our bourses, as it will only influence a higher volume of trade or push up stock prices in turn.

The fund should not change the fair value of the listed companies either. The problems in our capital market are fundamental, and we must look at the market holistically in order to understand why such problems arise.

What triggered the refinance scheme?

The stock market crash of 2010 left investors bankrupt and unable to pay back loans they had taken from brokers. Following this, in May of last year, the government announced a stock refinancing fund of Tk9bn with the desire to help out the ruined investors.

Essentially, this is a loan given to Investment Corporation Bangladesh (ICB) at a discounted interest rate of 5% from the Bangladesh Bank’s yearly profits. A portion of this fund, which has only recently been disbursed will be given to brokers at 7% rate for lending it to investors at 9% interest rate, with the hope that it will allow the affected investors to take more loans (also known as margins) so that they can reinvest in the stock market and pay back this and the original loans.

Why is the scheme’s failure inevitable?

A capital market (stock market or equity market) is one that contains a group of companies that do business in order to handover a profit to its investors. The price of small units (stocks) of the companies’ ownership generally goes up if a company performs well, or is presumed to perform well in the future, given the stock was not already overvalued, supposedly.

Having said that, an increase in the trading of stocks in the capital market will not help the publicly listed companies make more profits or perform any better, especially the manufacturing ones that have almost no exposure to the capital markets. In other words, trading of stocks has nothing to do with production and performance of most companies in the real economy.

Therefore, the compensated margin loan will not help investors make money in a market that is still considered to be overvalued without creating another market bubble.

If so, why do we have such refinance scheme?

“The fund will be disbursed to help bring stability in the stock market,” Bangladesh Bank Deputy Governor SK Sur Chowdhury told a press conference on May 29, 2013.

It is assumed that the fund, bearing only half of the on-going bank lending rate, will be given to market crash (2010) affected small-scale investors as margin loans so that they may invest in equity markets once again, and plough back enough profits to pay back interests of the margin along with previously held margins.

Contrary to the assumption above, the scheme, however, will only be assisting the affected small-scale investors in executing frequent trades using the margin loans, and also in turn increase the trading volume at the bourses.

So, how does higher volume help affected investors?

According to capital market experts, high volume of trades in the capital market attracts foreign investors because of the benefit in exiting the market at ease for an investor due to higher liquidity.

In simpler words, for me to sell a particular stock, one would need to be there on the trading floor who is willing to buy it from me. Higher volume of trades just makes such situation more likely.

However, this particularly does not help out the affected investors. Perhaps the sole purpose of the fund is to lure the affected investors back to the market.

Also, we currently have a very high volume of trades despite the scheme, don’t we?

The graph on the right may seem like a lie, but sadly it isn’t. The after-crash market’s annual trade volume is way above what we had experienced in the years before 2008, which makes the refinance scheme all the more pointless.

Also, the Tk9bn fund is an insignificant amount if we compare it with the yearly trade volume.

Bottom line

The capital market is performing quite well in recent times in terms of volume traded and movement of indices, which makes the scheme unnecessary. The fund of Tk9bn is public money (the fund is a portion of Bangladesh Bank’s profit that it pays to the government coffers each year) that could have been put to better use. 

Top Brokers