Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Muhith blasts media for ‘misreporting’ on black money amnesty

Update : 01 Jul 2014, 10:49 PM

Ruling out the scope to legalise black money, Finance Minister AMA Muhith yesterday blamed the media for reports on the scope of black money whitening.

Terming all the news reports on the provision utterly ‘nonsense’ and ‘meaningless’, he said the black money holders have to pay 10% penalty as per the law.

“I have kept my word on the black money whitening issue as no provision has been included in this fiscal year. So, there is no scope to legalise black money in the new budget,” the minister told reporters after a meeting with Deputy Managing Director of International Monetary Fund Naoyuki Shinohara at Economic Relations Division at Sher-e-Banglanagar.

In his concluding speech with the passage of Finance Bill 2014, Muhith on Saturday said the black money could be invested in the purchase of flats by paying a certain amount of tax for per square metre.

“If any taxpayer has not paid tax properly in the past, he/she can pay the due tax by paying the penal tax along with regular tax,” he said just before the passage of the bill on June 29 at the parliament.

The minister proposed the withdrawal of the provision of legalising black money through investments in treasury bonds.

According to the bill, anyone can regularise untaxed money by paying 10% tax along with regular tax under different slabs ranging from 10% to 25% in productive and income-generating sectors. The money can also be used to purchase land and residential apartments during FY2014-15.

Under the provision 19E of Income Tax Ordinance 1984, which is ‘voluntary disclosure of income’, people can legalise only their undeclared or untaxed, but legally earned money and taxmen will not raise questions on the sources of money if the taxpayers take advantage of the provision.

The section also allows people to invest money in any sector as the provision reads “the money could be invested in industrial undertakings, including its expansion; balancing, modernisation, renovation and extension of an existing industry; building or apartment or land; securities listed with a domestic stock exchange; and in any trade, commercial or industrial venture engaged in production of goods and services”.

However, the law said the provision will not be applied for the legalisation of money derived from any illegitimate source of income or from any criminal activities.

The National Board of Revenue officials have said there is no mechanism to properly detect what kind the money is, as the law does not clearly define what is black money and what is undisclosed money.

“In general terms, untaxed money is known as undisclosed money. Once you fail to disclose your income in the tax returns, the money becomes illegal. In addition, the income tax law allows people to invest their money in any sector and we cannot raise any questions,” a NBR high official said.

As the law does not have any time frame for legalising undisclosed money, people can take advantage at any time. So, no one is willing to legalise the money as they can take advantage even after two or three years, he added.

He also said if the NBR finds any illegal money, it can do nothing as there is no specific provision in the law on what to do if illegal money is found and therefore officials sometimes adjust the money with the returns.

According to a 2011 study endorsed by the Finance Ministry, black money accounted for 62.75% of the total GDP in 2009, while it accounted for only 7% of the GDP in 1973.

Between the fiscal years 1971-72 and 2012-13, nearly Tk13,808 crore was whitened. During the period, the NBR received taxes of Tk1,455 crore, which is less than 1% of the revenue collection target set for the fiscal year 2014-15.

Former NBR Chairman Muhammad Abdul Majid told the Dhaka Tribune yesterday that the money generated from any income becomes illegal money once it becomes untaxed, regardless of whether it is derived from legal or illegal sources.

“Black money is usually the money on which tax was not paid and for which the sources of income was undisclosed, but there is no clear definition on black money in the law, which creates the confusion. If any taxpayer does not pay taxes, he conceals information and evades tax,” he said.

During the 2007-08 period, when many people legalised their money, the government had made it permanent as the law did not have any time frame on when the deadline for such amnesty would expire, he added.

In response to a question on the size of such money in the economy, he said there is a parallel economy ongoing with such money which is reflected with people’s deposits in international banks like Swiss Bank and Singapore and people are now leading lavish lifestyles in Dubai or making second homes in Malaysia.

The government can easily scrap the provision by amending the law as the finance minister had already withdrawn the provision for investments in treasury bonds, the NBR official said.

“The government can amend the law any time, but the government’s will is a must for it, which seems insignificant,” he said.

Echoing the same, Majid said: “The provision should not continue as it offended the honest taxpayers and did not attract investments.”

If the government wants the discontinuation of the facility, it should make changes in the law by amending the provision, he added. 

Top Brokers